Chapter IX.—Of the Philosophers, who fell into Mistaken Notions, and Some of them
into Danger, by their Desire of Universal Knowledge.—Also of the Doctrines of Plato.
We ought, therefore, to aim at objects which are within our power, and exceed not the
capacities of our nature. For the persuasive influence of argument has a tendency to draw
most of us away from the truth of things, which has happened to many philosophers, who
have employed themselves in reasoning, and the study of natural science, and who, as often
as the magnitude of the subject surpasses their powers of investigation, adopt various devices
for obscuring the truth. Hence their diversities of judgment, and contentious opposition to
each others’ doctrines, and this notwithstanding their pretensions to wisdom. Hence, too,
popular commotions have arisen, and severe sentences, passed by those in power, appre-
hensive of the overthrow of hereditary institutions, have proved destructive to many of the
disputants themselves. Socrates, for example, elated by his skill in argumentation, indulging
his power of making the worse appear the better reason,3405 and playing continually with
the subtleties of controversy, fell a victim to the slander of his own countrymen and fellow-
citizens. Pythagoras, too, who laid special claim to the virtues of silence and self-control,
was convicted of falsehood. For he declared to the Italians that the doctrines which he had
received during his travels in Egypt, and which had long before been divulged by the priests
of that nation, were a personal revelation to himself from God. Lastly, Plato himself, the
gentlest and most refined of all, who first essayed to draw men’s thoughts from sensible to
intellectual and eternal objects, and taught them to aspire to sublimer speculations, in the
first place declared, with truth, a God exalted above every essence, but to him he added also
a second, distinguishing them numerically as two, though both possessing one perfection,
and the being of the second Deity proceeding from3406 the first. For he is the creator and
controller of the universe, and evidently supreme: while the second, as the obedient agent
of his commands, refers the origin of all creation to him as the cause. In accordance, therefore,
with the soundest reason, we may say that there is one Being whose care and providence
are over all things, even God the Word, who has ordered all things; but the Word being God
himself is also the Son of God. For by what name can we designate him except by this title
of the Son, without falling into the most grievous error? For the Father of all things is
properly considered the Father of his own Word. Thus far, then, Plato’s sentiments were
3405 This is almost identically the form of what Socrates (Apol. c. 2) declared to be the falsehood circulated
by his enemies to his prejudice. “But far more dangerous are those who began when you were children and took
possession of your minds with their falsehoods, telling of one Socrates, a wise man who…made the worse appear
the better cause” (λόγον, “reason”), Tr. Jowett, 1 (1874), 316. This example does peculiar discredit either to the
learning or the mental honesty of the author.
3406 Rather “deriving existence from,” “proceeding from,” gives strict idea, but may be confounded with the
technical “proceeding from” of the “filioque” controversy, which is quite another phrase.
Of the Philosophers, who fell into Mistaken Notions, and Some of them into Danger, by their Desire of Universal Knowledge.--Also of the Doctrines of Plato.
1442
Of the Philosophers, who fell into Mistaken Notions, and Some of them into…