Theology. These controversies bring us to
consider Jerome’s position as a theologian. Here he is admittedly
weak. He had no real interest in the subject. The first of his letters
which deals with theology, that written from the Desert to Pope
Damasus, points out clearly the difficulty raised by the difference of
phraseology of East and West, the Eastern speaking of one Essence and
three Substances, the Western, of one Substance and three Persons. But
he makes no attempt to grasp the reality lying behind these
expressions, and merely asks not to have the Eastern terms forced on
his acceptance, while he professes in the most absolute terms his
submission to the decision of the Bishop of Rome. This lack of genuine
theological interest best explains his conduct in relation to Origen,
his extravagant laudation of him at one time (46), his violent
condemnation at another (187). He was carried away by Origen’s
genius and industry in the department of biblical criticism and
exegesis in which he was himself absorbed, and though in his earlier
discussion of the Vision of Isaiah (22), which touched the doctrine of
the Trinity, he had put aside Origen’s view that the Seraphim
were the Son and the Spirit as wrongly expressing their relation to the
Father, the doctrinal question was feebly present to his thoughts, and
he repeated Origen’s exposition without blame as to the
pre-existence of souls and the restoration of Satan (Ruf. Apol. ii. 13,
Vol. iii. 467). When the subject of Origen’s orthodoxy was raised
at a later time, he was unaware of any inconsistency when he fell in
with the general condemnation of his doctrine. So with regard to
Eusebius of Cæsarea. In the Preface to the translation of his Book
on the Site and Names of Hebrew Places (485), he is “vir
admirabilis”; in his controversy with Rufinus, Eusebius is
nothing but a heretic. In his controversy with Augustin as to the
quarrel between St. Peter and St. Paul in Gal. ii., which he interpreted as fictitious and
pre-arranged with a view to bring
out St. Paul’s solution of the question about the Gentile
converts, he was manifestly in the wrong, and eventually seems to have
felt this, yet as one who was silenced rather than convinced. At a
later period he says to Augustin (Ep. cxxxiv.), “If the heretics
see that we hold divergent opinions they will say calumniously that
this is a result of hatred, whereas it is my firm resolution to love
you, to look up to you, to defer to you with admiration, and to defend
your opinions as my own.” His dread of heresy may be gathered
from passage in the Anti-Pelagian Dialogue (i. 28) in which he
expressly declares that, while sin can be forgiven, heresy, as being
impiety, is subject to the threat: “They that forsake the Lord
shall be consumed.” It is true that in his Catalogue he shows
wider sympathies, and defends himself in writing to Augustin for the
admission into it of men like Philo Judæus and Seneca. But this,
though it might have led him to the larger views of the heathen world
held by Origen and Clement, did not prevent his condemning to eternal
torments even the most virtuous of the heathen. He tells Marcella, a
Roman lady (41–42), that one object he has in writing to her is
to instruct her that the consul-elect Vettius Agorius Prætextatus,
who was known as a model of public and domestic virtue, and who had
then recently died, is in Tartarus, while their friend Lea, who had
died the same day, is in heaven.