Our author in the book more especially attended to, says, (p. 31. d. e.) He knows of
nobody who has any controversy with me in what he calls my loose way of arguing, in my
saying, “The nature of things seems to afford no good reason why the people of Christ should
not openly profess a proper respect to him in their hearts, as well as a true notion of him in
their heads.” And then, in that and the following page, proceeds to show what respect Mr.
S. and those that think with him, suppose men must profess in order to come to the Lord’s
supper; and (in p. 33. a.) speaks of such a profession as is equally honourable to Christ with
a profession of saving grace. And, as according to Mr. W. no profession discriminating what
is professed from common grace, can be required, so common grace must be supposed to
be a proper respect to Christ in the heart. Now let us see what Mr. S. says. “There is (says he)
an opposition between saving and common grace;—they have a contrariety one to another,
and are at war one with the other, and would destroy one the other.—Common graces are
lusts, and do oppose saving grace.” (Nat. of Sav. Conv. p. 9. d. e.) “Men that are in a natural
condition, such of them as are addicted to morality and religion, are serving their lusts
therein. The most orderly natural men do live an ungodly life;—yea, their very religion is
iniquity.“ (Ibid. p. 96, 97.)—“Their best works are not only sinful, but properly sins; they are
acted by a spirit of lust in all that they do.” (Saf. of App. p. 168. d.)—“Moral virtues do not
render men acceptable to God ; for though they look like virtues, yet they are lusts.” (Ibid.
p. 81.)—Now the question plainly is, Whether lust can be a proper respect to Christ in the
heart? And, Whether a profession which implies no more in it, be equally honourable to
Christ, as a credible profession of a gracious respect to him ?
1940
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.