Will, suffered their bodies to die, that it might be in their choice. to turn to good or
evil.”—“They who are acted by the Holy Spirit, are not held under any necessity, but have
liberty to turn themselves, and do what they will in this life.”
Thus, the Doctor in effect comes into that very notion of liberty, which the Calvinists
have; which he at the same time condemns, as agreeing with the opinion of Mr. Hobbes,
namely, The soul acting by its own choice, men doing good or evil according to their own free
choice, their being in that exercise which proceeds from their own free choice, having it in their
choice to turn to good or evil, and doing what they will.” So that if men exercise this liberty
in the acts of the Will themselves, it must be in exerting acts of Will according to their own
free choice; or, exerting acts of Will that proceed from their choice. And if it be so, then let
every one judge whether this does not suppose a free choice going before the free act of Will,
or whether an act of choice does not go before that act of the Will which proceeds from it.
And if it be thus with all free acts of the Will, then let every one judge, whether it will not
follow that there is a free choice going before the first free act of the Will exerted in the case!
And finally, let every one judge whether in the scheme of these writers there be any possib-
ility of avoiding these absurdities.
If liberty consists, as Dr. Whitby himself says, in a man’s doing what he will; and a man
exercises this liberty, not only in external actions, but in the acts of the Will themselves;
then so far as liberty is exercised in the latter, it consists in willing what he wills: and if any
say so, one of these two things must be meant, either, 1. That a man has power to will, as
he does will; because what he wills, he wills; and therefore power to will what he has power
to will. If this be their meaning, then all this mighty controversy about freedom of the Will
and self-determining power, comes wholly to nothing; all that is contended for being no
more than this, that the mind of man does what it does, and is the subject of what it is the
subject, or that what is, is; wherein none has any controversy with them. Or, 2. The meaning
must be, that a man has power to will as he chooses to will: that is, he has power by one act
of choice to choose another; by an antecedent act of Will to choose a consequent act: and
therein to execute his own choice. And if this be their meaning, it is nothing but shuffling
with those they dispute with, and baffling their own reason. For still the question returns,
wherein lies man’s liberty in that antecedent act of Will which chose the consequent act.
The answer according to the same principles must be, that his liberty in this also lies in his
willing as he would, or as he chose, or agreeable to another act of choice preceding that.
And so the question returns in infinitum, and the like answer must be made in infinitum:
in order to support their opinion, their must be no beginning, but free acts of Will must
have been chosen by foregoing free acts of Will in the soul of every man, without beginning.
560
SECTION V. Showing, that if the things asserted in these Evasions should…