This chapter is the only place in which Eusebius attempts to treat
the canon systematically, and in it he is speaking purely as an
historian, not as a critic. He is endeavoring to give an accurate
statement of the general opinion of the orthodox Church of his day in
regard to the number and names of its sacred books. He does not, in
this passage, apply to the various works any criterion of canonicity
further than their acceptance as canonical by the orthodox Church. He
simply records the state of the canon; he does not endeavor to form a
canon. He has nothing to do, therefore, with the nature and origin of
the books which the church accepts. As remarked by Weiss (Einleitung
in das N. T., p. 96), the influence of Eusebius in the formation of
the canon is very commonly overestimated. He contributed himself very
little; his office was to record the usage of the church of his age,
not to mould it.
The church whose judgment he
takes is, in the main, the church of the Orient, and in that church at
this time all the works which we now call canonical (and only those)
were already commonly accepted, or were becoming more and more widely
accepted as such. From the standpoint, then, of canonicity, Eusebius
divided the works which he mentions in this chapter into two classes:
the canonical (including the Homologoumena and the
Antilogomena) and the uncanonical (including the νόθοι and the ἀναπλ€σματα
αὶρετικῶν
ἀνδρῶν). But
the νόθοι he
connects much more closely with the Homologoumena and
Antilegomena than with the heretical works, which are, in fact,
separated from all the rest and placed in a class by themselves. What,
then, is the relation of the Homologoumena, Antilegomena,
and νόθοι to each
other, as Eusebius classifies them? The crucial point is the relation
of the νόθοι to
the ἀντιλεγόμενα. Lücke (Ueber den N. T. Kanon des Eusebius, p.
11 sq.) identified the two, but such identification is impossible in
this passage. The passages which he cites to confirm his view prove
only that the word Antilegomena is commonly employed by Eusebius
in a general sense to include all disputed works, and therefore, of
course, the νόθοι also; that
is, the term Antilegomena is ordinarily used, not as identical
with νόθοι, but as
inclusive of it. This, however, establishes nothing as to
Eusebius’ technical use of the words in the present passage,
where he is endeavoring to draw close distinctions. Various views have
been taken since Lücke’s time upon the relation of these
terms to each other in this connection; but, to me at least, none of
them seem satisfactory, and I have been led to adopt the following
simple explanation. The Antilegomena, in the narrower sense
peculiar to this summary, were works which, in Eusebius’ day,
were, as he believed, commonly accepted by the Eastern Church as
canonical, but which, nevertheless, as he well knew, had not always
been thus accepted, and, indeed, were not even then universally
accepted as such. The tendency, however, was distinctly in the
direction of their ever-wider acceptance. On the other hand, the
νόθοι were works which, although they had been used by the Fathers
and were quoted as γραφὴ by some of
them, were, at this time, not acknowledged as canonical. Although
perhaps not universally rejected from the canon, yet they were commonly
so rejected, and the tendency was distinctly in the direction of their
ever-wider rejection. Whatever their merit, and whatever their
antiquity and their claims to authenticity, Eusebius could not place
them among the canonical books. The term νόθοι, then, in
this passage, must not be taken, as it commonly is, to mean spurious or
unauthentic, but to mean uncanonical. It is in this sense, as against
the canonical Homologoumena and Antilegomena, that
Eusebius, as I believe, uses it here, and his use of it in this sense
is perfectly legitimate. In using it he passes no judgment upon the
authenticity of the works referred to; that, in the present case, is
not his concern. As an historian he observed tendencies, and judged
accordingly. He saw that the authority of the Antilegomena was
on the increase, that of the νόθοι on the
decrease, and already he could draw a sharp distinction between them,
as Clement of Alexandria could not do a century before. The distinction
drawn has no relation to the authenticity or original authority of the
works of the two classes, but only to their canonicity or uncanonicity
at the time Eusebius wrote.
This interpretation will help us
to understand the peculiar way in which Eusebius treats the Apocalypse,
and thus his treatment of it becomes an argument in favor of the
interpretation. He puts it, first among the Homologoumena with
an εἴγε
φανείη, and then
among the νόθοι with
an εἴ
φανείη. No one,
so far as I know, has explained why it should be put among the
νόθοι as an alternative to the Homologoumena, instead of
among the Antilegomena, which, on the common interpretation of
the relation of the classes, might be naturally expected. If the view
presented is correct, the reason is clear. The Antilegomena were
those works which had been disputed, but were becoming more and more
widely accepted as canonical. The Apocalypse could not under any
circumstances fall into this class, for the doubts raised against it in
the orthodox Church were of recent date. It occupied, in fact, a
peculiar position, for there was no other work which, while accepted as
canonical, was doubted in the present more than in the past. Eusebius
then must either put it into a special class or put it conditionally
into two different classes, as he does. If the doubts should become so
widespread as to destroy its canonicity, it would fall naturally into
the νόθοι, for then
it would hold the same position as the other works of that class. As an
historian, Eusebius sees the tendency and undoubtedly has the idea that
the Apocalypse may eventually, like the other Christian works of the
same class (the Shepherd, the Apocalypse of Peter, etc.), become one of
the νόθοι, one of
the works which, formerly accepted, is at length commonly denied to be
canonical: and so, as an historian, he presents the alternative. The
Apocalypse was the only work in regard to which any doubt could
exist.
Eusebius’ failure to
mention explicitly in this passage the Epistle to the Hebrews, has
caused considerable misunderstanding. The explanation, if the view
presented be adopted, is simple. Eusebius included it, I believe, among
the epistles of Paul, and did not especially mention it, simply because
there was no dispute about its canonicity. Its Pauline authorship had
been widely disputed as Eusebius informs us elsewhere, and various
theories had been proposed to account for it; but its canonicity had
not been doubted in the orthodox Church, and therefore doubts as to the
authorship of it did not in the least endanger its place among the
Homologoumena, as used here in a technical sense; and since
Eusebius was simply stating the works of each class, not discussing the
nature and origin of those works, he could, in perfect fairness,
include it in Paul’s epistles (where he himself believed it
belonged) without entering upon any discussion of it.
Another noticeable omission is
that of the Epistle of Clement to the Corinthians. All efforts to find
a satisfactory reason for this are fruitless. It should have been
placed among the νόθοι with the
Epistle of Barnabas, etc., as Eusebius’ treatment of it in other
passages shows. It must be assumed, with Holtzmann, that the omission
of it was nothing more nor less than an oversight.
Eusebius, then, classifies the
works mentioned in this chapter upon two principles: first, in relation
to canonicity, into the canonical and the uncanonical; and secondly, in
relation to character, into the orthodox (Homologoumena,
Antilegomena, which are canonical, and νόθοι,
which are uncanonical), and heterodox (which are not, and never have
been, canonical, never have been accepted as of use or authority). The
Homologoumena and Antilegomena, then, are both canonical
and orthodox, the ἀναπλ€σματα
αἱρετικῶν
ἀνδρῶν are
neither canonical nor orthodox, while the νόθοι occupy a
peculiar position, being orthodox but not canonical. The last-named are
much more closely related to the canonical than to the heterodox works,
because when the canon was a less concrete and exact thing than it had
at length become, they were associated with the other orthodox works
as, like them, useful for edification and instruction. With the
heretical works they had never been associated, and possessed in common
with them only the negative characteristic of non-canonicity. Eusebius
naturally connects them closely with the former, and severs them
completely from the latter. The only reason for mentioning the latter
at all was the fact that they bore the names of apostles, and thus
might be supposed, as they often had been—by Christians, as well
as by unbelievers—to be sacred books like the rest. The statement
of the canon gives Eusebius an opportunity to warn his readers against
them.
Upon Eusebius’ New
Testament Canon, see especially the work of Lücke referred to
above, also Westcott’s Canon of the New Testament, 5th
ed., p. 414 sq., Harnack’s Lehre der Zwölf Apostel,
p. 6 sq., Holtzmann’s Einleitung in das N.T., p. 154 sq.,
and Weiss’ Einleitung, p. 92 sq.
The greater part of the
present note was read before the American Society of Church History in
December, 1888, and is printed in Vol. I. of that Society’s
papers, New York, 1889, p. 251 sq.