the beginning, and with God, and in the bosom of the Father, so that by their relation the
absolute existence of the Lord should be done away. But his assertion that He was God, by
this absolute declaration detached from all relation to anything else, cuts off every subterfuge
from those who in their reasonings run into impiety; and, in addition to this, there is
moreover something else which still more convincingly proves the malignity of our adversar-
ies. For if they make out that to exist in something is an indication of not existing in the
strict sense, then certainly they allow that not even the Father exists absolutely, as they have
learnt in the Gospel, that just as the Son abides in the Father, so the Father abides in the
Son, according to the words of the Lord954. For to say that the Father is in the Son is equi-
226
valent to saying that the Son is in the bosom of the Father. And in passing let us make this
further inquiry. When the Son, as they say, “was not,” what did the bosom of the Father
contain? For assuredly they must either grant that it was full, or suppose it to have been
empty. If then the bosom was full, certainly the Son was that which filled the bosom. But if
they imagine that there was some void in the bosom of the Father, they do nothing else than
assert of Him perfection by way of augmentation, in the sense that He passed from the state
of void and deficiency to the state of fulness and perfection. But “they knew not nor under-
stood,” says David of those that “walk on still in darkness955.” For he who has been rendered
hostile to the true Light cannot keep his soul in light. For this reason it was that they did
not perceive lying ready to their hand in logical sequence that which would have corrected
their impiety, smitten, as it were, with blindness, like the men of Sodom.
But he also says that the essence of the Son is controlled by the Father, his exact words
being as follows:—“For He Who is and lives because of the Father, does not appropriate
this dignity, as the essence which controls even Him attracts to itself the conception of the
Existent.” If these doctrines approve themselves to some of the sages “who are without,” let
not the Gospels nor the rest of the teaching of the Holy Scripture be in any way disturbed.
For what fellowship is there between the creed of Christians and the wisdom that has been
made foolish956? But if he leans upon the support of the Scriptures, let him show one such
declaration from the holy writings, and we will hold our peace. I hear Paul cry aloud, “There
is one Lord Jesus Christ957.” But Eunomius shouts against Paul, calling Christ a slave. For
we recognize no other mark of a slave than to be subject and controlled. The slave is assuredly
a slave, but the slave cannot by nature be Lord, even though the term be applied to Him by
inexact use. And why should I bring forward the declarations of Paul in evidence of the
lordship of the Lord? For Paul’s Master Himself tells His disciples that He is truly Lord, ac-
954 S. John xiv. 11
955 Cf. Ps. lxxxii. 5.
956 Cf. 1 Cor. i. 20
957 Cf. 1 Cor. viii. 6.
433
After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the…