She waited a moment and then
said: Give me leave to invent a fanciful simile in order to illustrate
the matter before us: even though that which I suppose may be outside
the range of possibility. Grant it possible, then, in the art of
painting not only to mix opposite colours, as painters are always
doing, to represent a particular tint tint, μορφῆς.
Certainly in earlier Greek μορφὴ is
strictly used of “form,” “shape” (or the beauty
of it) only, and colours cannot be said to be mixed in imitation of
form. It seems we have here a late use of μορφὴ as =
“outward appearance”; so that we may even speak of
the μορφὴ of a
colour, or combinations of colours. So (214 A) the painter “works
up (on his palette) a particular tint of colour” (μορφὴν). Here it is the particular hue, in person or picture,
which it is desired to imitate. Akin to this question is that of the
proper translation of πρὸς τὴν
ὁμοιότητα
τοῦ
προκειμένου, which Sifanus and Krabinger translate “ad
similitudinem argumenti,” and which may either mean (1)
“to make the analogy to the subject matter of our question as
perfect as possible,” i.e. as a parenthesis, or (2)
“in imitation of the thing or colour (lying before the painter)
to be copied.” The last seems preferable (“to form the
given tint”).,
but also to separate again this mixture and to restore to each of the
colours its natural dye. If then white, or black, or red, or golden
colour, or any other colour that has been mixed to form the given tint,
were to be again separated from that union with another and remain by
itself, we suppose that our artist will none the less remember the
actual nature of that colour, and that in no case will he show
forgetfulness, either of the red, for instance, or the black, if after
having become quite a different colour by composition with each other
they each return to their natural dye. We suppose, I say, that our
artist remembers the manner of the mutual blending of these colours,
and so knows what sort of colour was mixed with a given colour and what
sort of colour was the result, and how, the other colour being ejected
from the composition, (the original colour) in consequence of such
release resumed its own peculiar hue; and, supposing it were required
to produce the same result again by composition, the process will be
all the easier from having been already practised in his previous work.
Now, if reason can see any analogy in this simile, we must search the
matter in hand by its light. Let the soul stand for this Art of the
painter γραφικῆς
τέχνης.; and let the natural atoms stand for
the colours of his art; and let the mixture of that tint compounded of
the various dyes, and the return of these to their native state (which
we have been allowed to assume), represent respectively the concourse,
and the separation of the atoms. Then, as we assume in the simile that
the painter’s Art tells him the actual dye of each colour, when
it has returned after mixing to its proper hue, so that he has an exact
knowledge of the red, and of the black, and of any other colour that
went to form the required tint by a specific way of uniting with
another kind—a knowledge which includes its appearance both in
the mixture, and now when it is in its natural state, and in the future
again, supposing all the colours were mixed over again in like
fashion—so, we assert, does the soul know the natural
peculiarities of those atoms whose concourse makes the frame of the
body in which it has itself grown, even after the scattering of those
atoms. However far from each other their natural propensity and their
inherent forces of repulsion urge them, and debar each from mingling
with its opposite, none the less will the soul be near each by its
power of recognition, and will persistently cling to the familiar
atoms, until their concourse after this division again takes place in
the same way, for that fresh formation of the dissolved body which will
properly be, and be called, resurrection.