44. “They,” you go on, “also take
advantage of other letters which they say Epiphanius wrote to them. But
he, too shall give account for all his doings before the judgment seat
of Christ, where great and small shall be judged without respect of
persons. Still, how can they rely on his letter which he wrote only
because we took him to task on the matter of the unlawful ordination of
Paulinianus and his associates; as in the opening of that very letter
he intimates?” What, I ask, is the meaning of this blindness? how
is it that he is immersed, as the saying goes, in Cimmerian darkness?
He says that we make a pretext, and that we have no letters from
Epiphanius against him, and he immediately adds, “How can they
rely on his letter, which he only wrote because he was taken to task by
us, in the matter of the unlawful ordination of Paulinianus and his
associates; as in the opening of that very letter he intimates?”
We have no such letter! And what letter then is that, which in its
opening sentence speaks of Paulinianus? There is something in the body
of the letter of which you are afraid to make mention. Well! He was
taken to task, you say, by you because of the age of Paulinianus. But
you yourself ordain a man presbyter, and send him out as an envoy and a
colleague. You have the boldness falsely to call Paulinianus a boy, and
then to send out your own boy presbyter. You likewise take Theoseca, a
deacon of the church of Thiria, and make him presbyter, and put weapons
into his hands against us, and make a misuse of his eloquence for our
injury. You alone are at liberty to trample on the rights of the
Church; whatever you do, is the standard of teaching; and you do not
blush to challenge Epiphanius to stand with you before the judgment
seat of Christ. The sequel of this passage is to the following effect: See Letter LI.,
which begins as John says, though Jerome denies it.he throws it in the teeth of
Epiphanius that he was the partner of his table and an inmate of his
house, and declares that they never had any talk together concerning
the views of Origen, and he supports what he says with the attestation
of an oath, saying: “He never showed, as God is witness, that he
had even the suspicion that our faith was not correct?” I am
unwilling to answer and argue acrimoniously, lest I seem to be
convicting a bishop of perjury. There are several letters of Epiphanius
in our possession. One to John himself, others to the bishops of
Palestine, and one of recent date to the pontiff of Rome; and in these
he speaks of himself as impugning his views in the presence of many,
and says that he was not thought worthy of a reply, “and the
whole Monastery,” he says, “is witness to what we in our
insignificance assert.”