In the early spring of 340 the presbyters
returned (see above) with a letter from a number of bishops, including
the Eusebian leaders, who had assembled at Antioch in January. This
letter is carefully dissected in the reply of the Roman Council, and appears to have
been highly acrimonious in its tone. Julius kept it secret for a time
(p. 111), hoping against hope that after all some of the Orientals
would come for the council; but at length he gave up all expectations
of the kind, and convoked the bishops of Italy, who examined the cases
of the various exiles (p. 114). All the old charges against Athanasius
were gone into with the aid of the Mareotic report (the ex parte
character of which Julius strongly emphasises) and of the account of
the proceedings at Tyre. The council had no difficulty in pronouncing
Athanasius completely innocent on all points. The charge of ignoring
the proceedings of a council was disposed of by pointing out the
uncanonical character of Gregory’s appointment (p. 115), and the
infraction by the complainants of the decrees of Nicæa. With
regard to Marcellus, he responded to the request of the bishops by
volunteering a written confession of his faith (p. 116, Epiph.
Hær. 72), which was in fact the creed of the Roman Church
itself (Caspari, Quellen iii. 28, note, argues that the creed
must have been tendered at an earlier visit, 336–337, but without
cogent reasons). Either Julius and his bishops were (like the fathers
of Sardica) very easily satisfied, or Marcellus exercised extreme
reserve as to his peculiar tenets (Zahn, p. 71, makes out the best case
he can for his candour). The other exiles were also pronounced
innocent, and the synod ‘restored’ them all. It remained to
communicate the result to the Oriental bishops. This was done by Julius
in a letter drawn up in the name of the council, and preserved by
Athanasius in his Apology. Its subject matter has been sufficiently
indicated, but its statesmanlike logic and grave severity must be
appreciated by reference to the document itself. It has been truly
called ‘one of the ablest documents in the entire
controversy.’ It is worth observing that Julius makes no claim
whatever to pass a final judgment as successor of S. Peter,
although the Orientals had expressly asserted the equal authority of
all bishops, however important the cities in which they ruled (p. 113);
on the contrary he merely claims that without his own consent,
proceedings against bishops would lack the weight of universal
consent (p. 118). At the same time he claims to be in possession of the
traditions of S. Paul and especially of S. Peter, and is careful
to found upon precedent (that of Dionysius) a claim to be
consulted in matters alleged against a bishop of Alexandria. This
claim, by its modesty, is in striking contrast with that which Socrates
(ii. 17) and Sozom. (iii. 8, 10) make for him,—that owing to the
greatness of his see, the care of all the churches pertained to him:
and this again, which represents what the Greek Church of the early
fifth century was accustomed to hear from Rome, is very
different from the claim to a jurisdiction of divine right which we
find formulated in Leo the Great.