Turning to ecclesiastical affairs, we find a certain
calm settling down upon the Church after the Council of Constantinople,
and an unwillingness to reopen the subjects of strife. Men used the
name of heretic rather as something to frighten their opponents, and
sought to identify opinions which they disliked with the Arianism of
the past, which all alike condemned. There were much fewer Councils of
Bishops and no General Council for fifty years (Ephesus, 431). But
other subjects of dispute arose, the Christian community being
saturated with Greek contentiousness. The first of these related to
Origenism. The works of the great and original church teacher of
Alexandria of the third century (~254) had
been little studied for above a hundred years, when a new interest in
them arose both in the East and the West. The earnest study of
Scripture which led to the formation of the Vulgate, or translation
from the original into the vulgar tongue of the Latin world, led to a
wish to consult the greatest textual writer and interpreter of
Scripture who had as yet appeared; and those who learned from his Bible
work to admire him were led also to study his doctrinal views. It
happened to Origen, as to many modern teachers, that his name came to
be identified with one or two prominent doctrines; and, as men speak of
Calvinism or Erastianism or Hegelianism, so they spoke of Origenism.
The doctrines which they connected with Origen were taken from his most
important work, the Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν, “on First
Principles.” They were mainly (1) his expressions relating to the
subordination of the Son to the Father, and (2) his eschatology. As to
the first of these, they took isolated expressions, such as, “The
Son does not see the Father,” or, “the Son is darkness in
comparison with the Father,” and they spoke of him as the father
of Arius; as to the second, they fastened upon his speculative ideas,
that the coming of men’s souls into this world was a fall from a
previous state of being; that men may rise into an angelic state; that
the material body is destined to pass away; and that in the
consummation of all things all spiritual beings, including the fallen
angels, will be schooled into obedience, so that the universe may be
brought back into harmony. Men were incapable of entering into the
general system of Origen, and still more of understanding his
historical position. The Pope Anastasius who condemned him in 404 says
plainly that he knows neither who Origen was nor when he lived (see
Vol. iii. 433); and they consequently took his tenets in an absolute
sense, and thought of him as denying the divinity of Christ, or the
condemnation of the wicked, or the resurrection of the body. His views
were most widely spread in Egypt, where the contrary tendency of
Anthropomorphism, that is, the conception of God as the subject of
human properties and passions, was also widely prevalent. Theophilus,
Bishop of Alexandria, at first was generally favourable to Origen, as
was also Jerome; but, through various causes, not unmixed with personal
feeling, he turned against Origenism in a fanatical and persecuting
temper. He procured the condemnation of Origenism by the Bishops of
Egypt, Syria, and Cyprus, and also by those of Rome and Italy; and he
pursued those who had fled from his persecution to Constantinople, and
branded Chrysostom, who had receive them, as a heretic. In all this he
was aided by Jerome, who translated his missives into Latin (see
Letters 86 to 100, 113 and 114). But the whole matter was transacted
without any Council being called; the Bishops were taken as speaking
the general sentiment, and their decisions were reinforced by a decree
of the Emperors (400).