We must now examine more closely the history of
Monarchian tendencies, and firstly in Rome. The sub-Apostolic Church, simply holding the
Divinity of Christ and the Unity of God, used language (see above)
which may be called ‘naively Monarchian.’ This holds good
even of Asiatic theology, as we find it in its earlier stage. The
baptismal creed (as we find it in the primitive basis of the
Apostles’ Creed) does not solve the problem thus presented to
Christian reflexion. Monarchianism attempted the solution in two ways.
Either the One God was simply identified with the Christ of the
Gospels and the Creeds, the Incarnation being a mode of the
Divine manifestation (Father as Creator, Son as Redeemer, Spirit as
Sanctifier, or the like): ‘Modalism’ or Modalistic
Monarchianism (including Patripassianism, Sabellianism, and later on
the theology of Marcellus); or (this being felt incompatible
with the constant personal distinction of Christ from the Father) a
special effluence, influence, or power of the one God was conceived of
as residing in the man Jesus Christ, who was accordingly Son of
God by adoption, God by assimilation: ‘dynamic’
Monarchianism or Adoptionism (‘Son’ and
‘Spirit’ not so much modes of the Divine self-realisation
as of the Divine Action). This letter, the echo but not the
direct survival of Ebionism, was later on the doctrine of Photinus; we
shall find it exemplified in Paul of Samosata; but our present concern
is with its introduction at Rome by the two Theodoti, the elder of whom
(a tanner from Byzantium) was excommunicated by Bishop Victor, while
the younger, a student of the Peripatetic philosophy and grammatical
interpreter of Scripture, taught there in the time of Zephyrinus. A
later representative of this school, Artemon, claimed that its opinions
were those of the Roman bishops down to Victor (Eus. H. E. v.
28). This statement cannot be accepted seriously; but it appears to be
founded on a real reminiscence of an epoch in the action and teachings
of the Roman bishops at the time. It must be remembered that the two
forms of Monarchianism—modalism and adoptionism—are, while
very subtly distinguished in their essential principle, violently
opposed in their appearance to the popular apprehension. Their doctrine
of God is one, at least in its strict unitarianism; but while to the
Modalist Christ is the one God, to the Adoptionist He is essentially
and exclusively man.. p. 123) is very delicate: both ideas are
covered by ‘Dasein’. The two forms of Monarchianism are
related exactly as the Catholic doctrine of the Trinity is to the
Nestorian. In the one case His
Personality is divine, in the other human. Now there is clear proof of
a strong Modalist tendency. p. 608),
and Cleomenes. Praxeas arrived in Rome under Victor (or earlier,
Harnack, p. 610), and combined strong opposition to Montanism, with
equally strong modalism in his theology. In both respects his influence
told upon the heads of the Church. Montanism was expelled, Modalism
tolerated, Theodotus excommunicated; ‘Duo negotia diaboli Praxeas
Romæ procuravit: prophetiam expulit et hæresin intulit:
Paracletum fugavit et Patrem crucifixit’. (Tert.) ‘Praxeas
hæresin introduxit quam Victor[inus] (perhaps a confusion with
Zephyrinus) corroborare curavit’ (‘Tertullian’
adv. Hær.) in the Roman Church at
this time; this would manifest itself in especial zeal against the
doctrine of such men as Theodotus the younger, and give some colour to
the tale of Artemon. Both Tertullian and Hippolytus complain bitterly
of the ignorance of those responsible for the ascendancy which this
teaching acquired in Rome (Ζεφυρῖνον
ἄνδρα
ἰδιώτην καὶ
ἄπειρον τῶν
ἐκκλησιαστικῶν
ὅρων, Hipp. ‘idiotes quisque
aut perversus,’ ‘simplices, ne dicam imprudentes et
idiotæ.’ Tert.). The utterances of Zephyrinus support
this: ‘I believe in one God, Jesus Christ’ (Hipp., see
above on the language of the sub-Apost. Church). The Monarchian
influences were strengthened by the arrival of fresh teachers from Asia
(Cleomenes and Epigonus, see note 2) and began to arouse lively
opposition. This was headed by Hippolytus, the most learned of the
Roman presbytery, and eventually bishop This
point is still in debate. Against it, see Lightfoot, S. Clement of
Rome (ed. 1890), for it, Döllinger Hipp. and Call., and
Neumann, Der Röm. Staat u. d. Allg. Kirche (Leipz.
1890). in
opposition to Callistus, the successor of Zephyrinus. The theology of
Hippolytus was not unlike that of Tertullian, and was hotly charged by
Callistus with ‘Ditheism.’ The position of Callistus
himself, like that of his predecessor, was one of compromise between
the two forms of Monarchianism, but somewhat more developed. A
distinction was made between ‘Christ’ (the divine) and
Jesus (the human); the latter suffered actually, the former indirectly
(‘filius patitur, pater vero compatitur.’ (Tert.) τὸν Πατέρα
συμπεπονθέναι
τῷ υἱ& 254·, Hipp.; it is clear
that under ‘Praxeas’ Tertullian is combating also the
modified Praxeanism of Callistus. See adv. Prax. 27, 29; Hipp.
ix. 7); not without reason does Hippolytus charge Callistus with
combining the errors of Sabellius with those of Theodotus. The
compromise of Callistus was only partially successful. On the one hand
the strictly modalist Sabellius, who from about 215 takes the place of Cleomenes
at the head of Roman Monarchianism (his doctrine of the υἱοπάτωρ, of the
Trinity as successive πρόσωπα,
‘aspects,’ of the One God, pure modalism as defined above)
scorned compromise (he constantly reproached Callistus with having
changed his front, Hipp.) was excommunicated, and became the
head of a sect. And the fierce opposition of Hippolytus failed to
command the support of more than a limited circle of enthusiastic
admirers, or to maintain itself after his death. On the other hand (the
process is quite in obscurity: see Harnack1, p. 620) the
theology of Hippolytus and Tertullian eventually gained the day. Novatian, whose ‘grande volumen’ (Jer.)
on the Trinity represents the theology of Rome about 250 a.d., simply ‘epitomises Tertullian,’ and that
in explanation of the Rule of Faith. As to the Generation of the
Son, he drops the ‘quando Ipse [Pater] voluit’ of
Tertullian, but like him combines a (modified)
‘subordination’ with the ‘communio
substantiæ’—in other words the ὁμοούσιον.
Monarchianism was condemned in the West; its further history belongs to
the East (under the name of Sabellianism first in Libya: see pp. 173,
sqq.). But the hold which it maintained upon the Roman Church
for about a generation (190–220) left its mark. Rome condemned
Origen, the ally of Hippolytus; Rome was invoked against Dionysius of
Alexandria; (Rome and) the West formulated the ὁμοούσιον at
Nicæa; Rome received Marcellus; Rome rejected the τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
and supported the Eustathians at Antioch; it was with Rome rather than
with the prevalent theology of the East that Athanasius felt himself
one. (Cf. also Harnack, Dg. 11, p. 622 sqq.)
Monarchianism was too little in harmony with the New Testament, or with
the traditional convictions of the Churches, to live as a formulated
theology. The ‘naive modalism’ of the ‘simplices quae
major semper pars credentium est’ (Tert.) was corrected as soon
as the attempt was made to give it formal expression But only
at Aquileia was the rule of faith adapted by the insertion of
impassibilis..
But the attempt to do so was a valuable challenge to the conception
of God involved in the system of the Apologists. To their abstract,
transcendent, philosophical first Principle, Monarchianism opposed a
living, self-revealing, redeeming God, made known in Christ. This was a
great gain. But it was obtained at the expense of the divine
immutability. A God who passed through phases or modes, now Father, now
Son, now Spirit, a God who could suffer, was not the God of the
Christians. There is some justice in Tertullian’s scoff at their
‘Deum versipellem.’