he will not give a definition the same as that of end; but will carry his definition of it to the
99
opposite extremity. Therefore also the two contraries234 of these will be separated from each
other by the same distance of opposition; and that which is without beginning, being contrary
to that which is to be seen by a beginning, will be a very different thing from that which is
endless, or the negation of end. If, then, they import both these attributes into the being of
God, I mean the negations of end and of beginning, they will exhibit this Deity of theirs as
a combination of two contradictory and discordant things, because the contrary ideas to
beginning and end reproduce on their side also the contradictionexisting between beginning
and end. Contraries of contradictories are themselves contradictory of each other. In fact,
it is always a true axiom, that two things which are naturally opposed to two things mutually
opposite are themselves opposed to each other; as we may see by example. Water is opposed
to fire; therefore also the forces destructive of these are opposed to each other; if moistness
is apt to extinguish fire, and dryness is apt to destroy water, the opposition of fire to water
is continued in those qualities themselves which are contrary to them; so that dryness is
plainly opposed to moistness. Thus, when beginning and end have to be placed (diametrically)
opposite each other235, the terms contrary to these also contradict each other in their
meaning, I mean, the negations of end and of beginning. Well, then, if they determine that
one only of these negations is indicative of the being (to repeat my former assertion), they
will bear evidence to half only of God’s existence, confining it to the absence of beginning,
and refusing to extend it to the absence of end; whereas, if they import both into their
definition of it, they will actually exhibit it so as a combination of contradictions in the way
that has been said; for these two negations of beginning and of end, by virtue of the contra-
diction existing between beginning and end, will part it asunder. So their Deity will be found
to be a sort of patchwork compound, a conglomerate of contradictions.
But there is not, neither shall there be, in the Church of God a teaching such as that,
which can make One who is single and incomposite not only multiform and patchwork,
but also the combination of opposites. The simplicity of the True Faith assumes God to be
that which He is, viz., incapable of being grasped by any term, or any idea, or any other
device of our apprehension, remaining beyond the reach not only of the human but of the
angelic and of all supramundane intelligence, unthinkable, unutterable, above all expression
in words, having but one name that can represent His proper nature, the single name of
All men are mortal. Some men are mortal. No men are mortal.
E O A No men are mortal. Some men are not mortal. All men are mortal. But between A and O, E and I, there
is no half-way.
234 Beginning (Contraries) Beginningless. Endless (Contraries) Ending.
235 ὑπεναντίως διακειμένων. The same term has been used to express the opposition between Ungenerate
and Generated: so that it means both Oppositions, i.e. Contraries and Contradictories.
189
Explanation of 'Ungenerate,' and a 'study' of Eternity.