AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I.
449
u-ith God ; and who go the length of assert-
ing that, when once they have reached the
height of perfection, even sins of thought
and ignorance are impossible for them. And
although in my former letter addressed to
Ctesiphon and aimed at their errors, so far
as time permitted, I touched upon a few
points in the book which I am now endeavour-
ing to hammer out, I shall adhere to the method of Socrates. What can be said on
both sides shall be stated ; and the truth will
thus be clear when both sides express their
opinions. Origen is peculiar in maintaining
on the one hand that it is impossible for
human nature to pass through life without
sin, and on the other, that it is possible for a
man, when he turns to better things, to be-
come so strong that he sins no more.
2. I shall add a few words in answer to
those who say that I am writing this work be-
cause I am inflamed with envy. I have never
spared heretics, and I have done my best to
make the enemies of the Church my own.
1 Helvidius wrote against the perpetual vir- ginity of Saint Mary. Was it envy that led me to answer him, whom I had never seen in
the flesh ? "Jovinianus, whose heresy is now being fanned into flame, and who disturbed
the faith of Rome in my absence, was so devoid
of gifts of utterance, and had such a pestilent
style that he was a fitter object for pity than
for envy. So far as I could, I answered him
also.' * Rufinus did all in his power to circulate the blasphemies of Origen and the treatise
" On First Principles" (llepi 'Apxtii'}, not in one city, but throughout the whole world. He
even published the first book of 4Eusebius'
" Apology for Origen " under the name of 6Pam- philus the martyr, and, as though Origen had
not said enough,' vomited forth a fresh vol- ume on his behalf. Am I to be accused of envy
because I answered him ? and was his elo-
quence such a rushing torrent as to deter me
through fear from writing or dictating any-
thing in reply ? 7 Palladius, no better than a villainous slave, tried to impart energy to the
1 He was a Roman lawyer. His treatise was written about A.D.
383. See Jerome's treatise against him in this volume.
* See introduction to Jerome's treatise against Jovinianus in this volume.
* See Rufinus' works, especially the " Prolegomena," and Jer-
ome's controversy with him in vol. iii. of this series.
* That is, Kuscbius of Cacsarea (A.D. 267-338), who was called
Pamphilus from his friendship with Famphilus the martyr.
* Suffered martyrdom A.L). 509. He erected a library at
Czsarca of 30,000 volumes. See Rufinus' Preface to his Apology in this series, vol. iii., with introductory note.
* See Rufinus on the adulteration of the works of Origen, in this
series, vol. iii. p. 421.
* Palladius, bishop of Hellenopolis, the biographer and trusted friend of Chrysostom. was born about 367. He visited Bethlehem
about 387 and formed a very unfavourable opinion of Jerome. He
highly commended Rufinus. According to Epiphanius, as well as Jerome, he was tainted with Origenism. Tillemont, however,
thinks that another Palladius may be referred to in these passages.
His accounts of Jerome and Rufinus are given in his " Historia
Lausiaca," c. 78 and 118.
same heresy, and to excite against me fresh
prejudice on account of my translation of the
Hebrew. Was I 'envious of such distin-
guished ability and nobility ? Even now the
2mystery of iniquity worketh, and every one chatters about his views : yet I, it seems, am
the only one who is filled with envy at the
glory of all the rest ; I am so poor a creature
that I envy even those who do not deserve
envy. And so, to prove to all that I do not
hate the men but their errors, and that I do
not wish to vilify any one, but rather lament
the misfortune of men who are deceived by
knowledge falsely so-called, I have made use of the names of Atticus and Critobulus in
order to express our own views and those of
our opponents. The truth is that all we who
hold the Catholic faith, wish and long that,
while the heresy is condemned, the men may
be reformed. At all events, if they will con- tinue in error, the blame does not attach to us
who have written, but to them, since they have
preferred a lie to the truth. And one short
answer to our calumniators, whose curses fall
upon their own heads, is this, that the Mani- chaean doctrine condemns the nature of
man, destroys free will, and does away with
the help of God. And again, that it is mani- fest madness for man to speak of himself as
being what God alone is. Let us so walk
along the royal road that we turn neither to
the right hand nor to the left ; and let us
always believe that the eagerness of our wills
is governed by the help of God. Should any
one cry out that lie is slandered and boast
that he thinks with us ; he will then show that
he assents to the true faith, when he openly
and sincerely condemns the opposite views.
Otherwise his case will be that described by
the prophet : ' " And yet for all this her treacherous sister Judah hath not returned
unto me with her whole heart, but feignedly." It is a smaller sin to follow evil which you
think is good, than not to venture to defend
what you know for certain is good. If we
cannot endure threats, injustice, poverty, how
shall we overcome the flames Of Babylon ?
Let us not lose by hollow peace what we have
preserved by war. I should be sorry to allow
my fears to teach me faithlessness, when
Christ has put the true faith in the power of
my choice.
1 Jerome was accused of envy or ill-will by Palladius. " Tanta fuit ejus invidia ut ab ea obrueretur virtus doctrinx. _ Cum ergo
multis diebus cum co yersatus esset sanctus Posidonins. dicit mihi in
aurem. " I ngenua quidem Paula, quz ejus curam gerit, prsemori- etur, liberata ab ejus invidia. Ut autem arbitror, propter hunc
yirum non habitabjt yir sanctus in his locis. sed ejus pervadet
invidia usque ad proprium fratrem." — Pallad. Hist. Luus., J 78, cf.
§82.
2 2 Thess. ii. 7.
3 Jer. iii. 10.