“Existing in the
Beginning,” he says, “not without beginning.” In what
fashion does he who plumes himself on his superior discernment
understand the oracles of God? He declares Him Who was in the beginning
Himself to have a beginning: and is not aware that if He Who is in the
beginning has a beginning, then the Beginning itself must needs have
another beginning. Whatever He says of the beginning he must
necessarily confess to be true of Him Who was in the beginning: for how
can that which is in the beginning be severed from the beginning? and
how can any one imagine a “was not” as preceding the
“was”? For however far one carries back one’s thought
to apprehend the beginning, one most certainly understands as one does
so that the Word which was in the beginning (inasmuch as It cannot be
separated from the beginning in which It is) does not at any point of
time either begin or cease its existence therein. Yet let no one be
induced by these words of mine to separate into two the one beginning
we acknowledge. For the beginning is most assuredly one, wherein is
discerned, indivisibly, that Word Who is completely united to the
Father. He who thus thinks will never leave heresy a loophole to impair
his piety by the novelty of the term “ungenerate.” But in
Eunomius’ next propositions his statements are like bread with a
large admixture of sand. For by mixing his heretical opinions with
sound doctrines, he makes uneatable even that which is in itself
nutritious, by the gravel which he has mingled with it. For he calls
the Lord “living wisdom,” “operative truth,”
subsistent power, and “life”:—so far is the
nutritious portion. But into these assertions he instils the poison of
heresy. For when he speaks of the “life” as
“generate” he makes a reservation by the implied opposition
to the “ungenerate” life, and does not affirm the Son to be
the very Life. Next he says:—“As Son of God, quickening the
dead, the true light, the light that lighteneth every man coming into
the world Cf.
S. John i. 9, good, and the bestower of good
things.” All these things he offers for honey to the
simple-minded, concealing his deadly drug under the sweetness of terms
like these. For he immediately introduces, on the heels of these
statements, his pernicious principle, in the words “Not
partitioning with Him that begat Him His high estate, not dividing with
another the essence of the Father, but becoming by generation glorious,
yea, the Lord of glory, and receiving glory from the Father, not
sharing His glory with the Father, for the glory of the Almighty is
incommunicable, as He hath said, ‘My glory will I not give to
another. Is. xlii. 8.’” These are his deadly
poisons, which they alone can discover who have their souls’
senses trained so to do: but the mortal mischief of the words is
disclosed by their conclusion:—Receiving glory from the Father,
not sharing glory with the Father, for the glory of the Almighty is
incommunicable, as He hath said, ‘My glory will I not give to
another.’ Who is that “other” to whom God has said
that He will not give His glory? The prophet speaks of the adversary of
God, and Eunomius refers the prophecy to the only begotten God Himself!
For when the prophet, speaking in the person of God, had said,
“My glory will I not give to another,” he added,
“neither My praise to graven images.” For when men were
beguiled to offer to the adversary of God the worship and adoration due
to God alone, paying homage in the representations of graven images to
the enemy of God, who appeared in many shapes amongst men in the forms
furnished by idols, He Who healeth them that are sick, in pity for
men’s ruin, foretold by the prophet the loving-kindness which in
the latter days He would show in the abolishing of idols, saying,
“When My truth shall have been manifested, My glory shall no more
be given to another, nor My praise bestowed upon graven images: for
men, when they come to know My glory, shall no more be in bondage to
them that by nature are no gods.” All therefore that the prophet
says in the person of the Lord concerning the power of the adversary,
this fighter against God, refers to the Lord Himself, Who spake these
words by the prophet! Who among the tyrants is recorded to have been
such a persecutor of the faith as this? Who maintained such blasphemy
as this, that He Who, as we believe, was manifested in the flesh for
the salvation of our souls, is not very God, but the adversary of God,
who puts his guile into effect against men by the instrumentality of idols and
graven images? For it is what was said of that adversary by the prophet
that Eunomius transfers to the only-begotten God, without so much as
reflecting that it is the Only-begotten Himself Who spoke these words
by the prophet, as Eunomius himself subsequently confesses when he
says, “this is He Who spake by the prophets.”