purposes. Valens, indeed, had divided the province of Cappadocia, when in 371 he made
Tyana a metropolis: and therefore Anthimus, bishop of Tyana, when he claimed the position
of a metropolitan, with authority over suffragans, was making a not unnatural inference in
regard to ecclesiastical limits from political rearrangements of territory, as Gregory of
Nazianzus says (Orat. xliii., 58), whereas Basil “held to the old custom,” i.e., to the traditional
unity of his provincial church, although after a while he submitted to what he could not
hinder (see Tillemont, ix., 175, 182, 670). But in the case of Eustathius of Berytus, which
was clearly in the Council’s mind, the Phœnician province had not been divided; it was in
reliance on a mere title bestowed upon his city, and also on an alleged synodical ordinance
which issued in fact from the so-called “Home Synod” that he declared himself independent
of his metropolitan, Photius of Tyre, and brought six bishoprics under his assumed jurisdic-
tion. Thus while the province remained politically one, he had de facto divided it ecclesiast-
ically into two. Photius petitioned Marcian, who referred the case to the Council of
Chalcedon, and it was taken up in the fourth session. The imperial commissioners announced
that it was to be settled not according to “pragmatic forms,” but according to those which
had been enacted by the Fathers (Mansi, vii., 89). This encouraged the Council to say, “A
pragmatic can have no force against the canons.” The commissioners asked whether it was
lawful for bishops, on the ground of a pragmatic, to steal away the rights of other churches?
The answer was explicit: “No, it is against the canon.” The Council proceeded to cancel
the resolution of the Home Synod in favour of the elevation of Berytus, ordered the 4th
Nicene canon to be read, and upheld the metropolitical rights of Tyre. The commissioners
also pronounced against Eustathius. Cecropius, bishop of Sebastopolis, requested them to
put an end to the issue of pragmatics made to the detriment of the canons; the Council
278
echoed this request; and the commissioners granted it by declaring that the canons should
everywhere stand good (Mansi, vii., 89–97). We may connect with this incident a law of
Marcian dated in 454, by which “all pragmatic sanctions, obtained by means of favour or
ambition in opposition to the canon of the Church, are declared to be deprived of effect”
(Cod. Justin, i., 2, 12).
To this decision the present canon looks back, when it forbids any bishop, on pain of
deposition, to presume to do as Eustathius had done, since it decrees that “he who attempts
to do so shall fall from his own rank (βαθμοῦ) in the Church. And cities which have already
obtained the honorary title of a metropolis from the emperor are to enjoy the honour only,
and their bishops to be but honorary metropolitans, so that all the rights of the real metro-
polis are to be reserved to it.” So, at the end of the 6th session the emperor had announced
that Chalcedon was to be a titular metropolis, saving all the rights of Nicomedia; and the
Council had expressed its assent (Mansi, xii., 177; cf. Le Quien, i., 602). Another case was
discussed in the 13th session of the Council. Anastasius of Nicæa had claimed to be inde-
pendent of his metropolitan Eunomius of Nicomedia, on the ground of an ordinance of
512
Canon XII.