9. He entered, taking Jesus with him.
ð ü è å í —i.e. not ‘from what province?’—for he knew this, Luke 23:6-7; nor, ‘of what parents?’—but whence? in reference to υἱὸςθεοῦ: cf. πόθενγένοςεὔχεταιεἶναι, Hom. Od. ñ. 373. Observe that the fear of Pilate is not mere superstition, nor does it enter into the Jewish meaning of υἱὸςθ.: but arises from an indefinite impression made on him by the Person and bearing of our Lord. We must not therefore imagine any fear of Him as being a ‘son of the gods,’in Pilate’s mind (so even Luthardt): this gives a wrong direction to his conduct, and misses the fine psychological truth of the narrative.
Our Lord, in His silence, was acting according to His own precept, Matthew 7:6. Notwithstanding Pilate’s fear of Him, he was not in earnest;—not determined to be led by his conscience, but had already given way to the unjust demands of the people; and He who saw his heart, knew how unworthy he was of an answer to so momentous a question. Besides, this silence was the most emphatic answer to all who had ears to hear it;—was a reference to what He had said before, ch. John 18:37, and so a witness to His divine origin. Would any mere man, of true and upright character, have refused an answer to such a question, so put? Let the modern rationalist consider this.