The second controversy (which also was disposed of
without any General Council) was that of Pelagianism. Pelagius and
Cælestius, monks of Britain, had come to Rome in 409, and
maintained the doctrine of Free Will and the possibility of a man
living without sin, against the Augustinian doctrine of Grace, which
asserted the helplessness of man and issued in absolute
predestinarianism. They passed into Africa with the crowds who were
escaping from Alaric’s invasion, and there confronted the
influence of Augustin. Condemned by a Council at Carthage in 413, they passed into
Palestine, and procured recognition from Councils held at Jerusalem and
Diospolis in 415, notwithstanding the presence of Orosius,
Augustin’s friend, and the accusations of the Gaulish Bishops,
Heros and Lazarus. Jerome was invited to write against them (pp. 272,
279), and their followers rose against him and burnt his monasteries
(p. 280, Augustin De Gest. Pel. c. 66), after which they visited
Ephesus and Rome, and were at first received by the Pope Zosimus; and
several Bishops, of whom the chief was Julian of Eclana, espoused their
cause. But Augustin’s influence prevailed in the West, while in
the East little interest was taken in a controversy which was
humanistic rather than strictly theological, and men’s minds were
being drawn to the questions of Christology, which led to the Nestorian
controversy and the Council of Ephesus (431).