Against I.—But all we who follow the words of the evangelists
state that God the Word was not made flesh by nature, nor yet was
changed into flesh; for the Divine is immutable and invariable.
Wherefore also the prophet David says, “Thou art the same, and
thy years shall not fail.” Ps. ci. 28 And this the
great Paul, the herald of the truth, in his Epistle to the Hebrews,
states to have been spoken of the Son. Heb. i. 12 And
in another place God says through the Prophet, “I am the Lord: I
change not.” Mal. iii. 6 If then the Divine
is immutable and invariable, it is incapable of change or alteration.
And if the immutable cannot be changed, then God the Word was not made
flesh by mutation, but took flesh and tabernacled in us, according to
the word of the evangelist. This the divine Paul expresses clearly in
his Epistle to the Philippians in the words, “Let this mind be in
you which was also in Christ Jesus: who, being in the form of God,
thought it not robbery to be equal with God: but made Himself of no
reputation and took upon Him the form of a servant.” Phil. ii. 5, 6,
7 Now it is plain from these words that the
form of God was not changed into the form of a servant, but, remaining
what it was, took the form of the servant. So God the Word was not made
flesh, but assumed living and reasonable flesh. He Himself is not
naturally conceived of the Virgin, fashioned, formed, and deriving
beginning of existence from her; He who is before the ages, God, and
with God, being with the Father and with the Father both known and
worshipped; but He fashioned for Himself a temple in the Virgin’s
womb, and was with that which was formed and begotten. Wherefore also
we style that holy Virgin θεοτόκος, not because she gave birth in natural manner to God, but
to man united to the God that had fashioned Him. Moreover if He that
was fashioned in the Virgin’s womb was not man but God the Word
Who is before the ages, then God the Word is a creature of the Holy
Ghost. For that which was conceived in her, says Gabriel, is of the
Holy Ghost. Matt. i. 23 But if the only begotten Word of
God is uncreate and of one substance and co-eternal with the Father it
is no longer a formation or creation of the Spirit. And if the Holy
Ghost did not fashion God the Word in the Virgin’s womb, it
follows that we understand the form of the servant to have been
fashioned, formed, conceived, and generated. But since the form was not
stripped of the form of God, but was a Temple containing God the Word
dwelling in it, according to the words of Paul “For it pleased
the Father that in him should all fulness dwell”
“bodily,” Coloss. i. 19, and ii. 9 we call the Virgin
not mother of man (ἀνθρωποτόκος) but mother of God (θεοτόκος), applying the former title to the fashioning and
conception, but the latter to the union. For this cause the child who
was born is called Emmanuel, neither God separated from human nature
nor man stripped of Godhead. For Emmanuel is interpreted to mean
“God with us”, according to the words of the Gospels; and
the expression “God with us” at once manifests Him Who for
our sakes was assumed out of us, and proclaims God the Word Who
assumed. Therefore the child is called Emmanuel on account of God Who
assumed, and the Virgin θεοτόκος on account of the union of the form of God with the
conceived form of a servant. For God the Word was not changed into
flesh, but the form of God took the form of a servant.