About the year 350 Hilary was consecrated Bishop
of Poitiers. So we may infer from his own words Syn. 91;
regeneratus pridem et in episcopatu aliquantisper manens.
The renderings ‘long ago’ and ‘for some time’
in this translation seem rather too strong.
that he had been a good while regenerate, and for some little time a
bishop, on the eve of his exile in 356 a.d. Whether, like Ambrose, he was raised directly
from lay life to the Episcopate cannot be known. It is at least
possible that this was the case. His position as a bishop was one
of great importance, and, as it must have seemed, free from special
difficulties. There was a wide difference between the Church
organisation of the Latin-speaking provinces of the Empire (with the
exception of Central and Southern Italy and of Africa, in each of which
a multitude of insignificant sees were dependent upon the autocracy of
Rome and Carthage respectively) and that of the Greek-speaking
provinces of the East. In the former there was a mere handful of
dioceses, of huge geographical extent; in the latter every town, at
least in the more civilised parts, had its bishop. The Western
bishops were inevitably isolated from one another, and could exercise
none of that constant surveillance over each other’s orthodoxy
which was, for evil as well as for good, so marked a feature of the
Church life of the East. And the very greatness of their position
gave them stability. The equipoise of power was too perfect, the
hands in which it was vested too few, the men themselves, probably, too
statesmanlike, for the Western Church to be infected with that nervous
agitation which possessed the shifting multitudes of Eastern prelates,
and made them suspicious and loquacious and disastrously eager for
compromise. It was, in fact, the custom of the West to take the
orthodoxy of its bishops for granted, and an external impulse was
necessary before they could be overthrown. The two great sees
with which Hilary was in immediate relation were those of Arles and
Milan, and both were in Arian hands. But it needed the direct
incitation of a hostile Emperor to set Saturninus against Hilary; and
it was in vain that Hilary, in the floodtide of orthodox revival in the
West, attacked Auxentius. The orthodox Emperor upheld the Arian,
who survived Hilary by eight years and died in possession of his
see. But this great and secure position of the Western bishop had
its drawbacks. Hilary was conscious of its greatness E.g. Trin.
viii. 1. The bishop is a prince of the Church. and strove to be worthy of it; but it was a
greatness of responsibility to which neither he, nor any other man,
could be equal. For in his eyes the bishop was still, as he had
been in the little Churches of the past, and still might be in quiet
places of the East or South, the sole priest,
sacerdos Sacerdos in
Hilary, as in all writers till near the end of the fourth century,
means ‘bishop’ always., of his
flock. In his exile he reminds the Emperor that he is still
distributing the communion through his presbyters to the Church.
This survival can have had none but evil results. It put both
bishop and clergy in a false position. The latter were degraded
by the denial to them of a definite status and rights of their
own. Authority without influence and information in lieu of
knowledge was all for which the former could hope. And this lack
of any organised means of influencing a wide-spread flock—such a
diocese as that of Poitiers must have been several times as large as a
rural diocese of England—prevented its bishop from creating any
strong public opinion within it, unless he were an evangelist with the
gifts of a Martin of Tours. It was impossible for him to excite
in so unwieldy a district any popular enthusiasm or devotion to
himself. Unlike an Athanasius, he could be deported into exile at
the Emperor’s will with as little commotion as the bishop of some
petty half-Greek town in Asia Minor.