that Jesus is the Messiah, and this is cause of distress to them: and they ask, what they shall
do? Hereupon the apostles direct them to believe that Jesus is the Messiah; which they believed
already, before they asked the question: but however, when they heard this, they believed
that Jesus was the Messiah. They now found it out, as a new thing they did not know of before,
and are glad at the joyful discovery; though just before they believed the same thing, and
the discovery filled them with distress.
In p. 47. b. whereas it is said concerning these new converts,—” That such were added
to the church, as were the saved“—Mr. W. says, the like appellation is given to the whole
church of Israel. And in this and the foregoing page, he insists, that these converts were
before in the church of Israel, and were not now admitted, but only continued as some of
God’s people. But if these things were so, they were the saved before their conversion to
Christianity, as much as after; and others that were in the Jewish church, that were not yet
converted to Christianity, were as much the saved as they. And then why is their being saved
spoken of as what was now brought to pass, and as a thing that distinguished the believing
Jews from others?
In the same page, c. Mr. W. says, “we do not dispute but that the apostles supposed and
believed in charity, so far as they had any thing to do to suppose or believe any thing about
it, that God had given these persons saving repentance, and a heart-purifying faith.” And
yet in p. 61. he speaks of the apostles as supposing the contrary of many of those that had
been admitted into the primitive church; in that they speak of them, as such temples of God
as might be destroyed: “which (says Mr. W.) cannot be true of sanctified persons, unless
they can fall from grace.”
In his answer to the argument from Philip and the eunuch he supposes, that believing
519
with all the heart is only such a belief of the doctrine of Christianity as unsanctified men
may have. And yet in that forementioned place, (Christ a King and Witness, p. 144.) he says,
a man before he is renewed by the Holy Ghost, has a view of the truth as a doubtful uncertain
thing. And in the book now especially attended to, he in effect owns the thing, which he
earnestly disputes against in reply to this argument. He greatly insists, that the phrase, with
all the hearty does not signify gracious sincerity; and yet he owns it does. (p. 51. e. and 52.
a. b.) He owns, that according to the usual way of speaking among mankind, both in our
days, and also in the times when the Scriptures were written, “god requires men to give him
their hearts, intending by it such a sincerity as God will own and accept; which be sure (says
he) is nothing less than a gracious sincerity; which never can be, unless the whole soul and
all its faculties be engaged for God.” Then afterwards adds, “But how will this any ways
prove, that when men use the same expressions, it must necessarily be understood in the
same sense?” And yet in the same breath, he had observed that god in thus using the phrase,
uses it according to the usual manner of speaking among mankind. He gives this reason,
why the phrase need not be understood in the same sense when used by men, that men are
1997
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.