Adv. Hær. II. 31. 2. The sentence
as it stands in Eusebius is incomplete. Irenæus is refuting the
pretended miracles of Simon and Carpocrates. The passage runs as
follows: “So far are they [i.e. Simon and Carpocrates] from being
able to raise the dead as the Lord raised them and as the apostles did
by means of prayer, and as has been frequently done in the brotherhood
on account of some necessity—the entire Church in that locality
entreating with much fasting and prayer [so that] the spirit of the
dead man has returned, and he has been bestowed in answer to the prayer
of the saints—that they do not even believe this can possibly be
done, [and hold] that the resurrection from the dead is simply an
acquaintance with that truth which they proclaim.”
This resurrection of the
dead recorded by Irenæus is very difficult to explain, as he is a
truth-loving man, and we can hardly conceive of his uttering a direct
falsehood. Even Augustine, “the iron man of truth,” records
such miracles, and so the early centuries are full of accounts of them.
The Protestant method of drawing a line between the apostolic and
post-apostolic ages in this matter of miracles is arbitrary, and based
upon dogmatic, not historical grounds. The truth is, that no one can
fix the point of time at which miracles ceased; at the same time it is
easy to appreciate the difference between the apostolic age and the
third, fourth, and following centuries in this regard. That they did
cease at an early date in the history of the Church is clear enough.
Upon post-apostolic miracles, see Schaff, Ch. Hist. II. p. 116
ff., J. H. Newman’s Two Essays on Biblical and Eccles.
Miracles, and J. B. Mozley’s Bampton lectures On
Miracles.