On
Cornelius, see above, chap. 39, note. 3. His epistle to Dionysius is no
longer extant. Dionysius’ epistle to him is likewise lost, and is
known to us only from what Eusebius tells us here. It was written after
the death of Fabius of Antioch (see below, §4), and therefore
probably in 253 (see above, chap. 39, note 7). It has been questioned
whether this synod of Antioch to which, according to Eusebius,
Dionysius referred, was really held, or only projected. The Libellus
Synodicus records it as an actual synod, but its authority is of no
weight. On the other hand, Eusebius’ words seem plainly to
indicate that he believed that the council was really held, for he
speaks of it as “the synod at Antioch”; had he
thought of it only as projected, he could hardly have referred to it in
such definite terms. In spite, therefore, of the doubts of Dittrich,
Hefele, and others, I am inclined to believe that Eusebius supposed
that the synod had actually been held in Antioch. Whether the epistle
of Dionysius warranted him in drawing that conclusion is another
question, which cannot be decided. I look upon it, however, as probable
that, had the synod been simply projected and failed to convene, some
indication of that fact would have been given by Dionysius, and would
have caused a modification of Eusebius’ statement.