The treatise, De Sancta Trinitate is one of those which are
attributed by some to S. Basil, by others to S. Gregory: but for the
purpose of showing the difficulties with which they had to deal, the
question of its exact authorship is unimportant. It
appears on the whole more probable that the treatise is the work of S.
Gregory; but it is found, in a slightly different shape, among the
Letters of S. Basil. (Ep. 189 in the Benedictine Edition.)The
most obvious objection alleged against their teaching was that which
had troubled the Western theologians before the Alexandrine
Council,—the objection that the acknowledgment of Three Persons
implied a belief in Three Gods. To meet this, there was required a
statement of the meaning of the term ὑπόστασις, and of the relation of ὀυσία to ὑπόστασις. Another objection, urged apparently by the same party as
the former, was directed against the “novelty,” or
inconsistency, of employing in the singular terms expressive of the
Divine Nature such as “goodness” or “Godhead,”
while asserting that the Godhead exists in plurality of Persons In what
sense this language was charged with “novelty” is not very
clear. But the point of the objection appears to lie in a refusal to
recognize that terms expressive of the Divine Nature, whether they
indicate attributes or operations of that Nature, may be predicated of
each ὑπόστασις
severally, as well as of the οὐσία,
without attaching to the terms themselves that idea of plurality which,
so far as they express attributes or operations of the οὐσία, must be excluded from them.. To meet this, it was required that the sense
in which the Unity of the Godhead was maintained should be more plainly
and clearly defined.