This was James, the Lord’s brother (Gal. i. 19), who, according
to the uniform tradition of the early church, was the Bishop of
Jerusalem. He evidently was the chief pastor, as he presides at this
conference, and when Judaizing teachers afterwards went down to Antioch
from Jerusalem they are spoken of as coming “from James”
(Gal. ii. 12). From this it has been inferred that he was the leader of a
Judaistic party, but this view is inconsistent with his address here
and also with Paul’s testimony who says that the
“pillar” apostles “imparted nothing” to him,
that is, did not correct or supplement his teaching. He was no doubt of
a conservative tendency respecting the questions in dispute and may not
have been always self-consistent, as Peter certainly was not, but there
can be no doubt of his substantial agreement with Paul. His doctrine of
justification by works as well as by faith in his epistle is not
against this view, since he uses both the words “faith” and
“works” in a different sense from Paul, meaning by the
former “belief” and by the latter the deeds which are the
fruit of the Christian life, instead of meritorious obedience to the
Mosaic law.—G.B.S.