The anti-Pelagian Dialogue is the last of Jerome’s
controversial works, having been written in the year 417, within three
years of his death. It shows no lack of his old vigour, though perhaps
something of the prolixity induced by old age. He looks at the subject
more calmly than those of the previous treatises, mainly because it lay
somewhat outside the track of his own thoughts. He was induced to
interest himself in it by his increasing regard for Augustin, and by
the coming of the young Spaniard, Orosius, in 414, from Augustin to sit
at his feet. Pelagius also had come to Palestine, and, after an
investigation of his tenets, at a small council at Jerusalem, in 415, presided over by Bishop John, and a
second, at Diospolis in 416, had been admitted to communion. Jerome
appears to have taken no part in these proceedings, and having been at
peace with Bishop John for nearly twenty years, was no doubt unwilling
to act against him. But he had come to look upon Pelagius as infected
with the heretical “impiety,” which he looked upon (i. 28)
as far worse than moral evil; and connected him, as we see from his
letter to Ctesiphon (CXXXIII.), with Origenism and Rufinus; and he
brings his great knowledge of Scripture to bear upon the controversy.
He quotes a work of Pelagius, though giving only the headings, and the
numbers of the chapters, up to 100 (i. 26–32); and, though at
times his conviction appears weak, and there are passages (i. 5, ii.
6–30, iii. 1) which give occasion to the observation that he
really, if unconsciously, inclined to the views of Pelagius, and that
he is a “Synergist,” not, like Augustin, a thorough
predestinarian, the Dialogue, as a whole, is clear and forms a
substantial contribution to our knowledge. Although its tone is less
violent than that of his ascetic treatises, it appears to have stirred
up the strongest animosity against him. The adherents of Pelagius
attacked and burned the monasteries of Bethlehem, and Jerome himself
only escaped by taking refuge in a tower. His sufferings, and the
interference of Pope Innocentius in his behalf, may be seen by
referring to Letters CXXXV.–CXXXVII., with the introductory notes
prefixed to them.