20. Again, when the Bishops said that the Word
must be described as the True Power and Image of the Father, in all
things exact ἀπαράλλακτον and like the Father, and as
unalterable, and as always, and as in Him without division (for never
was the Word not, but He was always, existing everlastingly with the
Father, as the radiance of light), Eusebius and his fellows endured
indeed, as not daring to contradict, being put to shame by the
arguments which were urged against them; but withal they were caught
whispering to each other and winking with their eyes, that
‘like,’ and ‘always,’ and ‘power,’
and ‘in Him,’ were, as before, common to us and the Son,
and that it was no difficulty to agree to these. As to
‘like,’ they said that it is written of us, ‘Man is
the image and glory of God 1 Cor. xi. 7.:’
‘always,’ that it was written, ‘For we which live are
alway 2 Cor. iv. 11.:’ ‘in Him,’ ‘In Him
we live and move and have our being Acts xvii. 28.:’
‘unalterable,’ that it is written, ‘Nothing shall
separate us from the love of Christ Rom. viii. 35, who shall
separate.:’ as to
‘power,’ that the caterpillar and the locust are called
‘power’ and ‘great power Joel ii. 25.,’ and that it is often said of the
people, for instance, ‘All the power of the Lord came out of the
land of Egypt Ex. xii. 41.:’ and there are others also,
heavenly ones, for Scripture says, ‘The Lord of powers is with
us, the God of Jacob is our refuge Ps. xlvi. 7..’ Indeed
Asterius, by title the sophist, had said the like in writing, having
learned it from them, and before him Arius vid.
supr. §8, note 3.
having learned it also, as has been said. But the Bishops discerning in
this too their dissimulation, and whereas it is written, ‘Deceit
is in the heart of the irreligious that imagine evil Prov. xii. 20.,’ were again compelled on their part to
collect the sense of the Scriptures, and to re-say and re-write what
they had said before, more distinctly still, namely, that the Son is
‘one in essence vid.
ad Afros. 5, 6. ad Serap. ii. 5. S. Ambrose tells us,
that a Letter written by Eusebius of Nicomedia, in which he said,
‘If we call Him true Son of the Father and uncreate, then are we
granting that He is one in essence, ὁμοούσιον,’ determined the Council on the adoption of the term.
de Fid. iii. n. 125. He had disclaimed ‘of the
essence,’ in his Letter to Paulinus. Theod. Hist. i. 4.
Arius, however, had disclaimed ὁμοούσιον already, Epiph. Hær. 69. 7. It was a word of old
usage in the Church, as Eusebius of Cæsarea confesses in his
Letter, infr. Tertullian in Prax. 13 fin. has the translation
‘unius substantiæ:’ (vid. Lucifer de non Parc.
p. 218.) as he has ‘de substantia Patris,’ in Prax.
4. and Origen perhaps used the word, vid. Pamph. Apol. 5. and
Theognostus and the two Dionysii, infr. §25, 26. And before
them Clement had spoken of the ἕνωσις τῆς
μοναδικῆς
οὐσίας,
‘the union of the single essence,’ vid. Le Quien in Damasc.
Fid. Orth. i. 8. Novatian too has ‘per substantiæ
communionem,’ de Trinit. 31.’ with the
Father: by way of signifying, that the Son was from the Father, and not
merely like, but the same in likeness The
Arians allowed that our Lord was like and the image of the Father, but
in the sense in which a picture is like the original, differing from it
in substance and in fact. In this sense they even allowed the strong
word ἀπαράλλακτος
unvarying [or rather
exact] image, vid. beginning of §20. which had been used by
the Catholics (vid. Alexander, ap. Theod. Hist. i. 3. p. 740.)
as by the Semiarians afterwards, who even added the words κατ᾽
οὐσίαν, or
‘according to substance.’ Even this strong phrase,
however, κατ᾽
οὐσίαν
ἀπαράλλακτος
εἰκὼν, or
ἀπαραλλάκτως
ὅμοιος, did not
appear to the Council an adequate safeguard of the doctrine. Athan.
notices de Syn. that ‘like’ applies to qualities
rather than to essence, §53. Also Basil. Ep. 8. n. 3.
‘while in itself,’ says the same Father, ‘it is
frequently used of faint similitudes and falling very far short of the
original.’ Ep. 9. n. 3. Accordingly, the Council
determined on the word ὁμοούσιον as implying, as the text expresses it, ‘the
same in likeness,’ ταὐτὸν τῇ
ὁμοιώσει, that the likeness might not be analogical. vid. the passage
about gold and brass, §23 below, Cyril in Joan. 1. iii. c. v. p.
302. [See below de Syn. 15, note 2.], and of shewing that the Son’s likeness
and unalterableness was different from such copy of the same as is
ascribed to us, which we acquire from virtue on the ground of
observance of the commandments. For bodies which are like each other
may be separated and become at distances from each other, as are human
sons relatively to their parents (as it is written concerning Adam and
Seth, who was begotten of him that he was like him after his own
pattern Gen. v. 3.); but since the generation of the Son from
the Father is not according to the nature of men, and not only like,
but also inseparable from the essence of the Father, and He and the
Father are one, as He has said Himself, and the Word is ever in the
Father and the Father in the Word, as the radiance stands towards the
light (for this the phrase itself indicates), therefore the Council, as
understanding this, suitably wrote ‘one in essence,’ that
they might both defeat the perverseness of the heretics, and shew that
the Word was other than originated things. For, after thus writing,
they at once added, ‘But they who say that the Son of God is from
nothing, or created, or alterable, or a work, or from other essence,
these the Holy Catholic Church anathematizes vid.
Euseb.’s Letter, supr..’ And by saying this, they shewed
clearly that ‘of the essence,’ and ‘one in
essence,’ are destructive of those catchwords of irreligion, such
as ‘created,’ and ‘work,’ and
‘originated,’ and ‘alterable,’ and ‘He
was not before His generation.’ And he who holds these,
contradicts the Council; but he who does not hold with Arius, must
needs hold and intend the decisions of the Council, suitably regarding
them to signify the relation of the radiance to the light, and from
thence gaining the illustration of the truth.