their profession and behaviour. So, p. 7. b. “If their outward profession and behaviour be the
ground of this judgment, then it is not the inward experience of the heart.“ P. 55. b. “Which
judgment must be founded on something beyond and beside their external calling, and
visible profession to comply with it, and to be separated for God: and therefore this judgment
must be founded, either upon revelation, or a personal acquaintance with their experiences,“
&c. In like manner he is abundant, from one end of his book to the other, in representing
as though I insisted on judging men by their inward and spiritual experiences, in some pecu-
liar manner. Which is something surprising, since there is not so much as a word said about
relating, or giving an account of, experiences, or what is commonly so called, as a term of
communion. Mr. W. (p 6.a.) pretends to quote two passages of mine, as an evidence, that
this is what I insist on. One is from the 5th page of my book. It is true, I there say thus, “It
is a visibility to the eye of the public charity, and not a private judgment, that gives a person
a right to be received as a visible saint by the public.” And I there say, “A public and serious
profession of the great and main things wherein the essence of true religion or godliness
consists, together with an honest character, an agreeable conversation, and good understand-
ing of the doctrines of Christianity, and particularly those doctrines that teach the grand
condition of salvation, and the nature of true saving religion; this justly recommends persons
to the good opinion of the public; whatever suspicions and fears any particular person, either
the minister, or some other, may entertain, from what he in particular has observed; perhaps
the manner of his expressing himself in giving an account of his experiences, or an obscurity
in the order and method of his experiences,“ &c.—But the words do not imply, it may be
demanded of the candidate, that he should give an account of his experiences to the minister,
or any body else, as the term of his admission into the church: nor had I respect to any such
thing. But I knew it was the manner in many places for those who hoped they were godly
persons, to converse with their neighbours, and especially with their minister, about their
experiences; whether it was required of them in order to their coming into the church, or
no; and particularly, I was sensible, that this was the manner at Northampton, for whose
sake especially I wrote; and I supposed it the way of many ministers, and people, to judge
of others’ state, openly and publicly, by the order and method of their experiences, or the
manner of their relating them. But this I condemn in the very passage that Mr. W. quotes;
and very much condemn in other writings of mine which have been published; and have
ever loudly condemned, and borne my testimony against.
There is one passage more, which Mr. W. adds to the preceding, and fathers on me, to
prove that I require an account of experiences in order to admission; pretending to rehearse
my words, with marks of quotation, saying as follows, (p. 6. a.) and as he further explains
himself elsewhere; “The proper visibility which the public is to have of a man’s being a saint,
must be on some account of his experience of those doctrines which teach the nature of true
saving religion.”—I have made long and diligent search for such a passage in my writings,
1909
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.