Introductory Notice
to
Excerpts of Theodotus; or, Selections
from the Prophetic Scriptures.
————————————
We
may thank Mr. Wilson,
the translator, for separating this collection, absolutely, from the
works of Clement of Alexandria, to which it has been made an
appendix. The reference to “our Pantænus” gives
the only colour for such a collocation with so great a name. It
is the work of a Montanist, perhaps, who may have had some relations
with the Alexandrian school; but it is hard to say precisely who of
three or four named Theodotus (all heretics), may have made the
compilation, more especially because disjointed and contradictory
fragments seem mixed up in it as it is commonly edited. Dupin
(perhaps too readily copying Valesius) appears to think Clement may
have been the compiler, but that, like the
Hypotyposes
, the work
was the product of days when he was imperfectly educated in Christian
truth. It seems to me more reasonable to conclude that these
excerpts, and what goes by the name of
Fragments from the
Hypotyposes
, are alike corrupt or forged documents, for which
Clement’s name has been borrowed, to give them some credit; and I
can desire no better authority for this opinion than that of Jeremiah
Jones, with the arguments to be found in his learned work on the
Canon
.
195
The wretched performance, therefore, is valuable chiefly
as illustrating certain heresies of the second century; but,
incidentally, it is of considerable importance as confirming the
orthodox writers in those books and doctrines to which it bears witness
in coincidence with them.
I regret that the Edinburgh editors give us not a line
of information as to their estimate of these extracts, or concerning
authorship and like matters of interest and natural
curiosity.
195
Vol. i. pp.
371–376. These
Selections
are often quoted as
“Eclogues.”