τὸ
λεγόμενον
κτίζεσθαι τῇ
φύσει καὶ τῇ
οὐσί& 139·
κτίσμα. also
infr. 60. Without meaning that the respective terms are
synonymous, is it not plain that in a later phraseology this would have
been, ‘not simply that He is in His Person a creature,’ or
‘that His Person is created?’ Athan.’s use of the
phrase οὐσία τοῦ
λόγου has already
been noticed, supr. i. 45, and passages from this Oration are
given in another connexion, supr. p. 70, note 15. The term is
synonymous with the Divine Nature as existing in the Person of the
Word. [Cf. Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2) b.] In the passage in the text
the οὐσία of the
Word is contrasted to the οὐσία of
creatures; and it is observable that it is implied that our Lord has
not taken on Him a created οὐσία.
‘He said not, Athan. remarks, ‘I became a creature, for the
creatures have a created essence;’ he adds that ‘He
created’ signifies, not essence, but something taking
place in Him περὶ
ἔκεινον,
i.e. some adjunct or accident (e.g. notes on de Decr. 22), or as
he says supr. §8, envelopment or dress. And infr.
§51, he contrasts the οὐσία and
the ἀνθρώπινον
of the Word; as in Orat. i. 41. οὐσία and ἡ ἀνθρωπότης; and φύσις and
σάρξ, iii. 34. init. and λόγος and
σάρξ, 38. init. And He speaks of the Son ‘taking on Him the
economy,’ infr. 76, and of the ὑπόστασις
τοῦ λόγου being one with ὁ
ἄνθρωπος, iv. 25, c. It is observed, §8, note, how this line of
teaching might be wrested to the purposes of the Apollinarian and
Eutychian heresies; and, considering Athan.’s most emphatic
protests against their errors in his later works, as well as his strong
statements in Orat. iii. there is no hazard in this admission.
His ordinary use of ἄνθρωπος for the manhood might quite as plausibly be perverted on the other
hand into a defence of Nestorianism. Vid. also the Ed. Ben. on S.
Hilary, præf. p. xliii. who uses natura absolutely for our
Lord’s Divinity, as contrasted to the dispensatio, and
divides His titles into naturalia and
assumpta.