Prolegomena
on the
Life and Works of
Rufinus.
————————————
Note.
—The References (where a simple number is given) are to the
pages in this Volume.
Tyrannius Rufinus
is chiefly known from his relation to Jerome, first as an
intimate friend and afterwards as a bitter enemy. The immense influence
of Jerome, through all the ages in which criticism was asleep, has
unduly lowered his adversary. But he has some solid claims of his own
on our recognition. His work on the Creed, besides its intrinsic
merits, must always be an authority as a witness to the state of the
creed as held in the Italian churches in the beginning of the 5th
century, as also to the state of the Canon and the Apocrypha at that
time. And it is to his translations that we are indebted for our
knowledge of many of the works of Origen, including the greatest of
them all, the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
. We are
the more grateful for his services because they were so opportune. The
works of Origen, which had been neglected in the West for a century and
to such an extent that the Pope Anastasius says (433) that he neither
knows who he was nor what he wrote, came suddenly into notice in the
last quarter of a century before Alaric’s sack of Rome
a.d.
385–410: and it was at this moment that
Rufinus appeared, according to his friend Macarius’ dream (439)
like a ship laden with the merchandize of the East, an Italian who had
lived some 25 years in Greek lands, and sufficiently equipped for the
work of a translator. Through his labours during the last 13 years of
that eventful time a considerable part of the works of the great
Alexandrian have floated down across the ocean of the Dark Ages, and,
while lost in their native Greek, have in their Latin garb come to
enrich the later civilization of the West.
a.d.
344–5: Rufinus was born at Concordia (Jer. Ep. v. 2. comp.
with Ep. x. and De Vir. Ill. §53) between Aquileia and Altinum, a
place of some importance, which was destroyed by the Huns in 452 but
afterwards rebuilt. His birth was about the year 344 or 345, he being
slightly older than Jerome. Nothing is known of his education or the
events of his youth; but that he was early acquainted with Jerome and
was interested in sacred literature is seen from the fact that in 368
when Jerome went with Bonosus to Gaul, Rufinus begged him to copy for
him the works of Hilary on the Psalms and on the Councils of the Church
(Jer. Ep. v. 2).
a.d.
372–3: His mother did not die till the year 397, as is seen
from Jerome’s mention of her (Letter LXXXI, 1), and it would
appear that both his parents were Christians. But he was not baptized
till about his 28th year. He was at that time living at Aquileia, where
he had embraced the monastic state, and was a member of the company of
young ascetics to which Jerome and Bonosus belonged. The presence among
them of Hylas (Jerome Letter III, 3) the freedman of Melania, the
wealthy and ascetic Roman matron, shows that that relation had already
begun which was afterwards of such importance in the life of Rufinus.
It must have been just before the breaking up of that company that he
was baptized, for Jerome, writing of him (Ep. iv. 2) in 374 from
Antioch says “He has but lately been washed and is as white as
snow.” He himself gives a full account of his baptism in his
Apology (436).
a.d.
373: When this company of friends was scattered, Rufinus joined
the noble Roman lady, Melania, in her pilgrimage to the East (Jer.
Letter iv. 2). He visited the monasteries of Egypt, and apparently
desired to remain there; but a persecution arose against the orthodox
monks from Lucius the Arian bishop of Alexandria, seconded by the
governor, both being prompted by the Arian Emperor Valens: the
monasteries were in many cases broken up (Sozomen, vi, 19, Socrates iv,
21–3, Rufinus Eccl.
Hist. ii, 3), and Rufinus
himself for a while suffered imprisonment and was then banished from
Egypt (430 Eccl. Hist. ii, 4). Rufinus probably on coming out of prison
joined Melania who had then settled at Diocæsarea (Pallad. Hist.
Laus. §117) on the coast of Palestine for the purpose of making a
home for the Egyptian exiles on their way to their various
destinations. He states in his Apology (466) that he was 6 years in
Egypt, and that he returned there again, after an interval, for two
years more. He was a pupil both of Didymus, then head of the
catechetical school, who wrote for him a treatise on the death of
infants (534), and of Theophilus, afterward Bishop of Alexandria (528),
and that he saw many of the well-known hermits (466), such as Serapion
and Macarius, whom he describes in his History of the Monks. Whether
Melania returned with him to Egypt, or whether she went to Jerusalem,
we do not know: it is also uncertain whether a journey which he made
(Eccl. Hist. ii. 8) to Edessa was undertaken at this time. The date of
the settlement of Melania on the Mount of Olives according to
Jerome’s Chronicle is 379, or, according to our present reckoning
of dates, 377. We may suppose that Rufinus joined her in 379. This was
his home for eighteen years, till the year 397.
a.d.
386: Rufinus was ordained at Jerusalem, probably about the time
when John, with whom he was closely connected, succeeded Cyril in the
Bishopric. The great resources of Melania were added to his own which
seem to have been not inconsiderable. He built habitations for monks on
the Mount of Olives, and employed them in learned pursuits, and in
copying manuscripts. On the arrival of Jerome at Bethlehem, the old
friendship was renewed, though not apparently with all its former
warmth. Jerome certainly at times visited Rufinus and once at least
stayed with him (465), and he and his friends brought
mss.
to be copied by the monks of the Mount of Olives
(465). He gave lectures on Christian writers and doctrine, of which a
satirical account is given at a later period by Jerome
2756
in his letter to Rusticus (cxxv,
§18). The nick-name Grunnius which he there gives him was probably
caused by some trick of the voice. But we may gather from Jerome that
he read the Greek church writers diligently and lectured upon them, a
study which enabled him to do much good work at a later time. It is
probable that he lectured in Greek, since he says in 397 that his Latin
was weak through disuse (439). We may set against Jerome’s
depreciatory description the account given by Palladius (Hist. Laus.
§118). “Rufinus, who lived with Melania, was a man of
congenial spirit, and of great nobility and strength of character. No
man has ever been known of greater learning or of gentler
disposition.” Palladius also speaks of the princely hospitality
of Melania and Rufinus: “They received,” he says,
“bishops and monks, virgins and matrons and helped them out of
their own funds: They passed their life offending none and being
helpers of the whole world.” It is said by Palladius that he had
heard from Melania that she had been present at the death of Pambas in
Egypt which took place in the year 385, and it is probable that Rufinus
accompanied her on this occasion. He himself records
2757
a journey which he made to Edessa and
Charrhoe, when he saw settlements of the monks like those which he had
previously seen in Egypt. But the date of this journey does not appear.
It may have been undertaken in order to visit some of the exiles from
Egypt before his establishment on the Mt. of Olives. He records also
the visits of the remarkable men who were entertained by him; Bacurius,
who had been king of the Ubii, and afterwards count of the Domestics
under Theodosius, and was governor or duke of Palestine when Rufinus
settled there; and Ædesius the companion of Frumentius the
Missionary to the tribes in the N. W. of India. But his chief interest
and occupation throughout seems to have been with his monks at Mt.
Olivet with perhaps some connection with the diocesan work of his
friend John, the Bp. of Jerusalem. Palladius records that Rufinus and
Melania were the means of restoring to the communion of the church 400
monks. What was this schism, which Palladius describes as being
“on account of Paulinus”? It is probable that the words
relate to the monks of Bethlehem whose alienation from the Church of
Jerusalem had been due to the ordination of Paulinian, Jerome’s
brother, by Epiphanius. We know that Rufinus before leaving Palestine
was reconciled to Jerome (Jer.
Ap. iii. 26, 33
); and we know also that
Jerome’s book against John, Bishop of Jerusalem, which describes
the schism was suddenly broken off;
2758
and that he
remained from that time forward at one with his Bishop. We may be
allowed to believe that the influence of Melania as well as Rufinus had
been exerted for some time previously to bring about this happy
result.
a.d.
382
:
Rufinus’ part in the
controversy thus terminated is partly known and partly the subject of
inference. The original source of discord is not known. It is possible
that Rufinus, who had been mentioned by Jerome in his Chronicle (
a.d.
378) as being, together with Florentius and
Bonosus, a specially distinguished monk, did not find himself included
in his friend’s Catalogue of Church writers (De Vir. III.)
published at Bethlehem.
a.d.
392
:
When Aterbius began the Origenist
troubles at Jerusalem, Rufinus, who treated him with merited scorn
(Jer. Ap. iii, 33) probably felt some resentment at Jerome who, by
“giving satisfaction” to the heresy hunter, had
countenanced his proceedings. Rufinus appears as Bishop John’s
adviser during the visit of Epiphanius (Jer. Letter li, 2, 6), as the
chief of a chorus of presbyters who applauded their own bishop and
derided Epiphanius as a “silly old man;”
2759
and as present when Epiphanius
remonstrated with his brother-bishop. He is also mentioned by
Epiphanius in his letter to John (Jer. Letter li. 6) as holding an
important place in the Church, “May God free you and all about
you, especially the presbyter Rufinus, from the heresy of Origen, and
all others.” This sentence will suggest to all who are familiar
with church-controversies a whole series of scenes in the schism which
continued between Bethlehem and Jerusalem during the next five years.
Jerome believed Rufinus to have injured him at every turn, to have
procured the abstraction of a Manuscript of his from the house occupied
by Fabiola on her visit to Bethlehem (Apol. iii, 4) perhaps to have
been in league with Vigilantius (Comp. Jer. Ep. lxi, 3 with Apol. iii,
4, 19). But such insinuations have the appearance rather of the
suspicions prompted by anger than of actual fact. In any case they were
condoned when the two old companions who had been so long parted by
ecclesiastical strife met together at the Church of the Resurrection at
a solemn eucharistic feast, and joined hands in token of
reconciliation, and when Jerome accompanied his friend some way on his
journey before their final parting (Jer. Vol. iii, 24).
a.d.
397: He arrived in Italy, in company with Melania, early in the
spring of 397. They were there received by Paulinus of Nola with great
honour.
2760
Melania went on at once to Rome;
but Rufinus stopped at the monastery of Pinetum near Terracina. His
welcome by the Abbot Urseius and the philosopher Macarius, and their
request to him to translate various Greek books, amongst others
the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
of
Origen, are described in his Prefaces to the Benedictions of the
Patriarchs, the Apology of Pamphilus and the translations of Origen
(417, 418, 420, 439). The preface to Origen’s chief work (427)
had the worst and most lasting results. He says that, being aware of
the odium attaching to the name of Origen, he had feared to translate
the work: but that the example of Jerome (whom he does not name but
whose great ability he extols) in translating Origen encourages him to
follow in his steps. This Preface, with this translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, was
published in Rome early in the year 398, Rufinus having moved there to
stay with Melania.
a.d.
400–403: At Rome he lived in the circle of Melania, her son
Publicola and his wife Albina, with their daughter the younger Melania
and her husband Pinianus, to whom we may probably add the Pope
Siricius, and certainly Apronianus, a young noble whom he speaks of as
his son in the faith (435, 564). Jerome’s friend Eusebius of
Cremona was also in Rome, and on friendly terms with him (445). But on
the appearance of the work of Origen with Rufinus’ Preface, a
great ferment arose leading to the violent controversy between Rufinus
and Jerome which is described in the Preface to their Apologies (434,
482).
a.d.
398: Meanwhile, Rufinus had left Rome probably in 398, having
obtained the usual Literæ Formatæ from the Pope Siricius, who
died that year, to introduce him to other churches.
2761
We hear of him at Milan, where in the
presence of the Bishop, Simplicianus,
2762
he met Eusebius of Cremona, and heard
him read out a letter of Theophilus containing some passages from
the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, against
which he vehemently protested (490).
a.d.
399–408: He then, having probably visited his native city of
Concordia, where his mother,
2763
possibly his
father also (430, 502) was still living, took up his abode at Aquileia.
There he was welcomed by the bishop, Chromatius, by whom he had been
baptized some 26 or 27 years before. Rufinus probably arrived at
Aquileia in the beginning of 399, and remained
there 9 or 10 years. It was
during this period that all his principal works except the Commentary
on the Benedictions of the patriarchs, the translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
and
Pamphilus’ Apology, and the book on adulterations of Origen were
composed. It was soon after his settlement at Aquileia that he heard
from Apronianus of the letter of Jerome to Pammachius and Oceanus
2764
expressing his anger against him for
the mention he had made of Jerome in the Preface to the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
. The
conciliatory letter to Rufinus which accompanied this and which was an
answer to a friendly one from Rufinus
2765
was not sent on by Jerome’s
friends (489); and Rufinus, thinking that his old friend had completely
turned against him, composed his Apology (434–482) which drew
forth Jerome’s reply (482–541). This controversy is placed
in full before the reader of this volume in an English translation,
with prefatory notes. It may therefore be treated very shortly
here.
Rufinus’ Apology is an
answer to Jerome’s letter to Pammachius and Oceanus. It is
addressed to Apronianus of Rome. He makes a profession of his Christian
standing and faith, especially on the points raised by the Origenistic
controversy; he describes the circumstances which had led him to
translate the books of Origen, and defends his method of translation,
which, he says, has been misrepresented by men sent from the East to
lay snares for him. His method, he declares, was the same which had
been used by Jerome, who boasted that through him the Latins knew all
that was good in Origen and nothing of the bad. Where he found passages
in Origen’s writings, in flagrant contradiction to the orthodox
opinion he had maintained elsewhere, he concluded that the passage had
been falsified by heretics, and restored the more orthodox statement
which he believed to have been originally there. He then turns round
upon Jerome and points out that, in his Commentaries on the Ephesians,
written some 10 years before, to which he specially referred in his
Letter as showing his freedom from heresy, he had practically adopted
the opinions now imputed to Origen as heretical, such as the fall of
souls from a previous state into the prison house of earthly bodies,
and the universal restoration of spiritual beings.
In the second book he clears
himself from the imputation of following Origen and Plato in believing
in the lawfulness of using occasional falsehood in the government and
training of men. But he imputes to his adversary a systematic use of
falsehood in reference to his reading heathen authors, while he
professed in his letter to Eustochium (Jer. Ep. xxii) to have solemnly
promised never even to possess them. He then takes a wider view of
Jerome’s writings, showing how, in this Letter to Eustochium, his
books against Jovinian, etc., he had by his satirical pictures held up
to ridicule the various classes of Christians, clergy, monks, virgins:
how he had praised Origen indiscriminately as a teacher second only to
the Apostles: how he had defamed men like Ambrose, and therefore his
present accusations were little worth: how he boasted of having taken
as his teachers not only Origenists like Didymus or heretics like
Apollinarius, but heathen like Porphyry, and had made his translation
of the Old Testament under the influence of the Jew Baranina (whose
name Rufinus perverts into Barabbas). He concludes by summarizing his
accusations and calling upon the reader to choose between him and his
opponent.
This Apology was only sent to a
few friends of Rufinus (530); but portions of it became known to
Jerome’s friends and his brother Paulinian (493) carried them to
Bethlehem, together with Rufinus’ Apology addressed to Pope
Anastasius. Jerome had also before him the letter of Anastasius to John
Bishop of Jerusalem (509) showing his dislike of Rufinus’
proceedings. On these he grounds his own Apology, which was originally
in two books and was addressed to Pammachius and Marcella
a.d.
402.
In the first book he blames
Rufinus’ breach of friendship after the reconciliation which had
taken place at Jerusalem; he then shows that he was compelled to
translate the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
in order
to show what it really was. He declares that the Apology of Origen
translated by Rufinus as the work of Pamphilus was really written by
Eusebius; that Origen had been condemned by Theophilus and Anastasius,
by East and West alike, and by the decree of the Emperors. He defends
himself for having used heathen and heretical teachers, and help of a
Jewish scholar in translating the Old Testament. As to his Commentaries
on the Ephesians he declares that he merely put side by side the
opinions of various commentators, indicating at times his knowledge
that some were heretical: and as to his anti-Ciceronian dream, he
ridicules the idea that a man can be bound by his night
visions.
In the second book he criticizes
Rufinus’ Apology addressed to Anastasius as to both its style and
its matter, and blames him for his treatment of Epiphanius, and
endeavours to implicate him in the imputation of heresy. He then
defends his translation of the Old Testament, showing by copious
quotations from the Prefaces to the Books that he had done nothing
condemnatory of the Septuagint, whose version he had himself translated
into Latin and constantly used in familiar expositions.
This Apology was brought to
Rufinus at Aquileia by a merchant who was leaving again in two days
(522). Chromatius no doubt urged him, as he urged Jerome (520) not to
continue the controversy and he yielded. He wrote, however, a private
letter to Jerome, which has been lost, sending him an accurate copy of
his Apology, and while declining public controversy, yet declaring that
he could have said even more than before, and divulged things which
would have been worse to Jerome than death. Jerome in his answer
written
a.d.
403, which forms B. iii of his
Apology, declares that the controversy is Rufinus’ fault, and
defends his friends for their conduct towards him, even in holding back
the conciliatory letter written in 399; but shows how a way might still
be open for friendship. He touches again upon most of the points dwelt
on in the previous books, defending himself and accusing Rufinus, and
ends by declaring that his bitter reply was necessitated first by
Rufinus’ threats, and secondly by his abhorrence of heresy, from
all complicity with which he must at any price clear
himself.
This book closed the controversy. Rufinus did not reply, Jerome
did not relent. Nothing in Rufinus’ subsequent writings reflects
on Jerome; but Jerome is never weary of expressing his hatred of
Rufinus, speaking of him after his death as “the
Scorpion”
2766
and writing
malignant satirical descriptions of him like that in his letter to
Rusticus.
2767
It may be observed, however,
that notwithstanding the violent words used on both sides, it was
possible for eminent churchmen to esteem and befriend both parties.
Augustine, on receiving Jerome’s Apology, laments, in words which
must have been felt by Jerome as a severe reproach, that two such men,
so loved by the churches, should thus tear each other to pieces.
Chromatius, while he kept up communications with Jerome, and supplied
him with funds for his literary work, was also the friend and adviser
of Rufinus.
Rufinus’ friends at
Aquileia, like those at the Pinetum and at Rome, were anxious to gain
from him a knowledge of the great church-writers of the East, and
especially of Origen. No one at Aquileia seems to have known Greek. He
makes excuses in his Prefaces (430, 563, 565, etc.) for the difficulty
of the task and his own short-comings which seem to be partly
conventional, partly genuine. But he did a work which he alone or
almost alone at that period was qualified to do. His translations of
Origen and Pamphilus were already known. We learn from Jerome (536)
that Rufinus had translated parts of the LXX. He now translated
Eusebius’ Church History, and added to it two books of his own;
he translated the so-called Recognitions of Clement, which till then
were almost unknown in Italy. He wrote a History of the Monks of the
East, partly from personal knowledge, partly from what he had heard or
read of them. And he translated the Commentaries of Origen upon the
Heptateuch or 1st seven books of Scripture, except Numbers and
Deuteronomy; and those on the Epistle to the Romans. He also wrote his
exposition of the Creed (541–563), and probably some other works
which have not come down to us.
a.d.
400–402: The first part of his stay at Aquileia was troubled
by the controversy with Jerome. He also received from his friends at
Rome the intelligence that his Preface and translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
had been
brought to the notice of the Pope Anastasius, by Pammachius and
Marcella (430); and probably the letter of the Pope to Venerius Bishop
of Milan, which is quoted in Anastasius’ letter to John of
Jerusalem (433) was also brought to his knowledge.
a.d.
400: Though there is no reason to suppose, as has been often done,
that the Pope passed sentence upon him, still less that he summoned him
to Rome. Rufinus was so far affected by what he heard of the adverse
feeling excited in the Pope’s mind toward him that he thought it
desirable to write an explanation or apology (430–2) vindicating
his action in the translation of Origen, and giving an exposition of
his own belief on some of the principal points dealt with in the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
. From
the letter of Anastasius to John of Jerusalem we gather that John had
written to him in the interest of Rufinus, and had blamed
Jerome’s friends at Rome, perhaps also Jerome himself, for the
part they had taken in reference to him. It is a curious fact that this
letter was known to Jerome but not to Rufinus during the controversy
(509); but it can hardly be inferred with any certainty from this that
John had changed sides and favoured Jerome at Rufinus’
expense.
a.d.
408: After 8 or 9 years at Aquileia Rufinus returned to Rome. His
friend Chromatius of Aquileia had died in 405. Anastasius of Rome had
also passed away (
a.d.
402), and his successor
Innocentius was without prejudice against Rufinus. Melania was either
there or with Paulinus at Nola. Her son Publicola had died in 406, but
his widow Albina was with her, and her granddaughter the younger
Melania with her husband Pinianus. The siege of Rome by Alaric was
impending, and the whole party were starting by way of Sicily and
Africa, in both of which Melania had property, intending eventually to
reach Palestine. He joined their “religious company” as he
tells us in the Preface to Origen on Numbers (568) which, according to
Palladius (Hist. Laus. 119) formed a vast caravan with slaves, virgins
and eunuchs; and he was with them in Sicily when Alaric burned Rhegium
(568) the flames of which they saw across the straits.
This translation of Numbers was
his last work. He was at that time suffering in his eyes; and he died
soon afterwards in Sicily, as we learn from Jerome’s malicious
words “The Scorpion now lies underground between Enceladus and
Porphyrion.”
2768
The undying
hatred of Jerome towards him has unduly lowered him in the estimation
of the Church. He was far below Jerome in literary ability, but in
their great controversy he displayed more magnanimity than his rival,
being willing to forego a public answer to his provoking
apology. He was highly
esteemed by the eminent churchmen of his time and the Bishops near whom
he lived. Chromatius of Aquileia was his friend; for Petronius of
Bologna he wrote his monastic history, for Gaudentius of Brixia he
translated the Clementine Recognitions, for Laurentius (perhaps of his
native Concordia) he composed his work on the Creed. Paulinus of Nola
continued his friendship for him to the end. Above all Augustine speaks
of him as the object of love and of honour; and, in his reply to
Jerome
2769
who had sent him his Apology,
says: “I grieved, when I had read your book, that such discord
should have arisen between persons so dear and so intimate, bound to
all the churches by a bond of affection and of
renown.”
We may conclude this notice by
two quotations from writers who lived shortly after the death of
Rufinus; the first of which shows how unfairly the fame of Jerome has
pressed on the memory of his antagonist, while the second may be taken
as the verdict of unprejudiced history. Pope Gelasius, at a Council at
Rome in 494, drew up a list of books to be received in the church, in
which he says of Rufinus: “He was a religious man, and wrote many
books of use to the Church, and many commentaries on the Scripture;
but, since the most blessed Jerome infamed him on certain points, we
take part with him (Jerome) in this and in all cases in which he has
pronounced a condemnation.” (Migne’s Patrologia vol. lix.
col. 175). On the other hand Gennadius, in his list of Ecclesiastical
writers (c. 17) says: “Rufinus, the presbyter, of Aquileia, was
not the least of the church-teachers, and showed an elegant genius in
his translations from Greek into Latin;” and, after giving a list
of his writings, he continues: “He also replied in two volumes to
him who decried his works, showing convincingly that he had exercised
his powers through the might which God had given him, and for the good
of the church, and that it was through a spirit of rivalry that his
adversary had employed his pen in defaming him.”
2756
“He came in with a slow and stately step; he spoke with a
broken utterance, sometimes with a kind of disjointed sobs rather than
words. He had a pile of tomes upon the table; and then, with a frown
and a contraction of the nostrils, and his forehead wrinkled up, he
snapped his fingers to call the attention of his audience. What he said
had no depth in it; but he criticized others, and pointed out their
defects, as though he would exclude them from the Senate of Christian
teachers. He was rich, and entertained freely, and many flocked round
him in his public appearances. He was as luxurious as Nero at home, as
stern as Cato abroad; as full of contradictions as the
Chimæra.”
2757
Hist.
Eccl. ii. 8
.
2758
For the date of this work, see the Note prefixed to it in the
translation of Jerome’s works, Vol. vi. of this
series.
2759
See Jerome’s expressions in his book
“Against John
of Jerusalem”
c. 11, which evidently refer to Rufinus:
“grinning like a dog and turning up his nose.”
2760
Paulinus Ep. xxix, 12.
2761
Jer. Ep. cxxvii, 9
Ap. iii. 21
.
2762
Successor of Ambrose, and Bishop
a.d.
397–400. See the Letter of Anastasius to him. Jer. Ep.
xcv.
2763
She died soon after. See Jerome Ep. lxxxi, 1.
2764
Jer. Ep. lxxxiv.
2765
See Jer. Ep. lxxxi, 1.
2766
Jer. Ep. cxxvii. 10.
2767
Jer. Ep. cxxv.
2768
Jer. Pref. to Comm. on Ezek. B. I.
2769
Aug. Letter 73 (In Jerome’s Letters No. 110).