swer: Either you fail in your proof, and so it concerns no one at all; or you succeed and then
it still has no concern with us. For they have borne their own burden, whether it be good
or bad; and we indeed believe that it was good. But of whatever character it was, yet it was
their own; just as your bad men have borne their own burden, and neither you theirs nor
they yours. But the common and most evil burden of you all is schism. This we have already
often said before. Show us, therefore, not the names of bishops, but the names of our em-
perors and judges, who have perished in persecuting you. For this, is what you had proposed,
this is what you had promised, this is what you had caused us most eagerly to expect. "Hear,"
he says, "Macarius perished, Ursacius perished, and all your counts perished in like manner,
by the vengeance of God." You have mentioned only two by name, and neither of them was
emperor. Who would be satisfied with this, I ask? Are you not utterly dissatisfied with
yourself? You promise that you will mention a vast number of emperors and judges of our
party who perished in persecuting you; and then, without a word of emperors, you mention
two who were either judges or counts. For as to what you add, "And all your counts perished
in like manner by the vengeance of God," it has nothing to do with the matter. For on this
principle you might some time ago have closed your argument, without mentioning the
name of any one at all. Why then have you not made mention of our emperors, that is to
say, of emperors of our communion? Were you afraid that you should be indicted for high
treason? Where is the fortitude that marks the Circumcelliones? And further, what do you
mean by introducing those whom you mentioned above in such numbers? They might with
more right say to you, Why did you seek us out? For they did nothing to assist your cause,
and yet you mentioned them by name. What kind of man, then, must you be, who fear to
mention those by name, who, as you say, have perished? At any rate, you might mention
more of the judges and counts, of whom you seem to feel no fear. But yet you stopped at
Macarius and Ursacius. Are these two whom you mention the vast number of whom you
spoke? Are you thinking of the lesson which we learned as boys? For if you were to ask of
me what number two is, singular or plural, what could I answer, except that it was plural?
But even so I am still not without the means of reply. I take away Macarius from your list;
for you certainly have not told us how he perished. Or do you maintain that any one who
persecutes you, unless he be immortal on the face of this earth, is to be deemed when he
dies to have died because of you? What if Constantine had not lived to enjoy so long a reign,
and such prolonged prosperity, who was the first to pass many decrees against your errors?
And what if Julian, who gave you back the basilicas, had not been so speedily snatched away
from life?2253 In that case, when would you make an end of talking such nonsense as you
do, seeing that even now you are unwilling to hold your tongues? And yet neither do we
2253 The reign of Constantine lasted about thirty-two years, from 306 to 337 A.D. Julian succeeded Constan-
tius, and reigned one year and seven months, dying at the age of thirty, in a war against the Persians, in 363 A.D.
1149
Chapter 93