‘Fallere et effugere’ was in fact the
problem which now confronted them. It seems to have been agreed at an
early stage, perhaps it was understood from the first, that some
formula of the unanimous belief of the Church must be fixed upon to
make an end of controversy. The Alexandrians and
‘Conservatives’ confronted the Arians with the traditional
Scriptural phrases (pp. 163, 491) which appeared to leave no doubt as
to the eternal Godhead of the Son. But to their surprise they were met
with perfect acquiescence. Only as each test was propounded, it was
observed that the suspected party whispered and gesticulated to one
another, evidently hinting that each could be safely accepted, since it
admitted of evasion. If their assent was asked to the formula
‘like to the Father in all things,’ it was given with the
reservation that man as such is ‘the image and glory of
God.’ The ‘power of God’ elicited the whispered
explanation that the host of Israel was spoken of as δύναμις
κυρίου, and that even the locust
and caterpillar are called the ‘power of God.’ The
‘eternity’ of the Son was countered by the text, ‘We
that live are alway (2 Cor.
iv. 11)!’ The fathers
were baffled, and the test of ὁμοούσιον, with
which the minority had been ready from the first, was being forced (p.
172) upon the majority by the evasions of the Arians. When the day for
the decisive meeting arrived it was felt that the choice lay between
the adoption of the word, cost what it might, and the admission of
Arianism to a position of toleration and influence in the Church. But
then, was Arianism all that Alexander and Eustathius made it out to be?
was Arianism so very intolerable, that this novel test must be imposed
on the Church? The answer came (Newman Ar. 4 p. 252) from Eusebius of Nicomedia. Upon
the assembling of the bishops for their momentous debate (ὡς δὲ ἐζητεῖτο
τῆς πίστεως ὁ
τρόπος, Eustath.) he
presented them with a statement of his belief. The previous course of
events may have convinced him that half-measures would defeat their own
purpose, and that a challenge to the enemy, a forlorn hope, was the
only resort left to him Or
possibly Theodoret, &c., drew a wrong inference from the words of
Eustathius (in Thdt. i. 8), and the γράμμα was
not submitted by Eusebius, but produced as
evidence against him; in this case it must have been, as Fleury
observes, his letter to Paulinus of Tyre.. At any rate the
statement was an unambiguous assertion of the Arian formulæ, and
it cleared the situation at once. An angry clamour silenced the
innovator, and his document was publicly torn to shreds (ὑπ᾽
ὄψει πάντων,
says an eye-witness in Thdt. i. 8). Even the majority of the Arians
were cowed, and the party were reduced to the inner circle of five
(supra). It was now agreed on all hands that a stringent formula
was needed. But Eusebius of Cæsarea came forward with a last
effort to stave off the inevitable. He produced a formula, not of his
own devising (Kölling, pp. 208 sqq.), but consisting of the
creed of his own Church with an addition intended to guard against
Sabellianism (Hort, Two Diss. pp. 56, sq. 138). The
formula was unassailable on the basis of Scripture and of tradition. No
one had a word to say against it, and the Emperor expressed his
personal anxiety that it should be adopted, with the single improvement
of the ὁμοούσιον. The
suggestion thus quietly made was momentous in its result. We cannot but
recognise the ‘prompter’ Hosius behind the Imperial
recommendation: the friends of Alexander had patiently waited their
time, and now their time was come: the two Eusebii had placed the
result in their hands. But how and where was the necessary word to be
inserted? and if some change must be made in the Cæsarean formula,
would it not be as well to set one or two other details right? At any
rate, the creed of Eusebius was carefully overhauled clause by clause,
and eventually took a form materially different from that in which it
was first presented, vol. 2, p. 227. The main alterations were (1) The
elimination of the word λόγος and
substitution of υἱ&
231·ς in the principal place. This
struck at the theology of Eusebius even more directly than at that of
Arius. (2) The addition not only of ὁμοούσιον τῷ
πατρί, but also
of τούτεστιν
ἐκ τῆς
οὐσίας τοῦ
πατρός between μονογενῆ and θεόν as a further
qualification of γεννηθέντα
(specially against Euseb. Nicom.: see his letter in
Thdt. i. 6). (3) Further explanation of γεννηθέντα
by γ.
οὐ
ποιηθέντα, a glance at a favourite argument of Arius, as well as at
Asterius. (4) ἐνανθρωπήσαντα
added to explain σαρκωθέντα, and so to exclude the Christology which characterised
Arianism from the first. (5) Addition of anathematisms directed against
all the leading Arian doctrines., and with affinities to
the creeds of Antioch and Jerusalem as well as Cæsarea.