a. Demons
and Miracles. The writings of Athanasius are singularly free from
the tendency to indulge in the marvellous. The death of Arius he
regards as a judgment, and relates it with a certain awe-struck
sobriety. The φήμη of
Julian’s death in the Narrat. ad Ammon. comes less under
the head of ecclesiastical miracle than under that of τὰ θειᾶ τῶν
πρηγμάτων (Herod.
ix. 100, cf. Grote v. 260 sq.); whereas the Vita swarms with miraculous
and demoniacal stories, some (passed over in silence by Newman and
other apologists for the Life) indescribably silly (e.g.
§§53, 63). Hence even Cave allows that the Vita
contains things ‘tanto viro indigna.’ But it must be
observed (1) that Antony disclaims, and his biographer disclaims for
him, inherent miraculous power. His miracles are wrought by Christ in
answer to prayer, and he prefers that those who desire his help should
obtain what they want by praying for themselves (cf. also §49).
(2) That again and again (esp. §§16–43) he insists on
the absolute subjection of all evil powers to God, and their
powerlessness to injure believers in Christ. (3) That Athanasius
recognises σημεῖα
(in the sense of miracles, see Letter 49, §9, note 9) as a
known phenomenon in the case both of bishops and of monks. (4) That his
language about demons and the power of the sign of the Cross in
dispersing them is quite of a piece with what is related in the
Vita (see notes passim). (5) On the clairvoyance
of Antony, and one or two kindred matters which offer points of contact
with phenomena that have been recently the subject of careful research,
notes will be found below giving modern references. On the whole, one
could wish that Athanasius, who is in so many ways surprisingly in
touch with the modern mind (supra, introd. to de Incar
and Prolegg. ch. iv. §2 d and §3), had not written a
biography revealing such large credulity. But we must measure this
credulity of his not by the evidential methods of our own day, but by
those of his own. If we compare the Vita, not with our modern
biographies but with those, say, of Paul and Hilarion by Jerome, its
superiority is striking (this is pointed out by W. Israël in
Zeitschr für Wiss. Theol. 1878, pp. 130, 137, 145, 153).
For myself I should certainly prefer to believe that Athanasius had not
written many things in the Vita: but I would far rather he had
written them all than the one passage Hist. Ar. §38
fin.