do we believe that now also the bread which is consecrated by the Word of God is changed
into the Body of God the Word. For that Body was once, by implication, bread, but has been
consecrated by the inhabitation of the Word that tabernacled in the flesh. Therefore, from
the same cause as that by which the bread that was transformed in that Body was changed
to a Divine potency, a similar result takes place now. For as in that case, too, the grace of
the Word used to make holy the Body, the substance of which came of the bread, and in a
manner was itself bread, so also in this case the bread, as says the Apostle2039, “is sanctified
504
by the Word of God and prayer”; not that it advances by the process of eating2040 to the
stage of passing into the body of the Word, but it is at once changed into the body by means
of the Word, as the Word itself said, “This is My Body.” Seeing, too, that all flesh is nourished
by what is moist (for without this combination our earthly part would not continue to live),
just as we support by food which is firm and solid the solid part of our body, in like manner
we supplement the moist part from the kindred element; and this, when within us, by its
faculty of being transmitted, is changed to blood, and especially if through the wine it receives
the faculty of being transmuted into heat. Since, then, that God-containing flesh partook
for its substance and support of this particular nourishment also, and since the God who
2039 1 Tim. iv. 5.
2040 by the process of eating, διὰ βρώσεως. There is very little authority for καὶ πόσεως which follows in some
Codd. If Krabinger’s text is here correct, Gregory distinctly teaches a transmutation of the elements very like
the later transubstantiation: he also distinctly teaches that the words of consecration effect the change. There
seems no reason to doubt that the text is correct. The three Latin interpretations, “a verbo transmutatus,” “statim
a verbo transmutatus,” “per verbum mutatus,” of Hervetus, Morell, and Zinus, all point to their having found
πρὸς τὸ σῶμα διὰ τοῦ λόγου μεταποιούμενος in the text: and this is the reading of Cod. Reg. (the other reading
is πρὸς τὸ σῶμα τοῦ λόγου). A passage from Justin Mart., Apol. ii. p. 77, also supports Krabinger’s text. Justin
says, “so we are taught that that food which has been blessed by the pronouncing of the word that came from
Him, which food by changing nourishes our blood and flesh, is the flesh and blood of that Incarnate Jesus.” As
to the nature of the change (πρὸς τὸ σῶμα μεταποιούμενος), another passage in Gregory (In Baptism. Christi,
370 A) should be compared: “The bread again, was for a while common bread, but when the mystic word shall
have consecrated it (ἱερουργήσῃ), it is called, and moreover is, the body of Christ.” He says also at the end of
this chapter, “He gives these gifts by virtue of the benediction through which He transelements(μεταστοιχειώσας)
the natural quality (φύσιν) of these visible things to that immortal thing.” Harnack does not attempt to weaken
the force of these and other passages, but only points out that the idea of this change does not exactly correspond
(how could it?) with the mediæval scholastically-philosophical “transubstantiation.” Gregory’s belief is that, just
as the Word, when Christ was here in the flesh, rendered holy His body that assimilated bread, which still in a
manner remained bread, so now the bread is sanctified by the Word of God and by prayer. “The idea,” says
Neander, “of the repetition of the consecration of the Λόγος had taken hold of his mind.” The construction is
προϊ& 241·ν (ὥστε) γενέσθαι εἰς τὸ σῶμα τοῦ λόγου, “eo progrediens, ut verbi corpus evadat.”
952
Chapter XXXVII