Chapter III.—A Statement of the Reason Why Matthew Enumerates One Succession
of Ancestors for Christ, and Luke Another.
5. Furthermore, as to those critics who find a difficulty in the circumstance that Matthew
enumerates one series of ancestors, beginning with David and travelling downwards to
Joseph,671 while Luke specifies a different succession, tracing it from Joseph upwards as far
as to David,672 they might easily perceive that Joseph may have had two fathers,—namely,
one by whom he was begotten, and a second by whom he may have been adopted.673 For
it was an ancient custom also among that people to adopt children with the view of making
sons for themselves of those whom they had not begotten. For, leaving out of sight the fact
that Pharaoh’s daughter674 adopted Moses (as she was a foreigner), Jacob himself adopted
his own grandsons, the sons of Joseph, in these very intelligible terms: “Now, therefore, thy
two sons which were born unto thee before I came unto thee, are mine: Ephraim and
104
Manasseh shall be mine, as Reuben and Simeon: and thy issue which thou begettest after
them shall be thine.”675 Whence also it came to pass that there were twelve tribes of Israel,
although the tribe of Levi was omitted, which did service in the temple; for along with that
one the whole number was thirteen, the sons of Jacob themselves being twelve. Thus, too,
we can understand how Luke, in the genealogy contained in his Gospel, has named a father
for Joseph, not in the person of the father by whom he was begotten, but in that of the
father by whom he was adopted, tracing the list of the progenitors upwards until David is
reached. For, seeing that there is a necessity, as both evangelists give a true narrative,—to
wit, both Matthew and Luke,—that one of them should hold by the line of the father who
begat Joseph, and the other by the line of the father who adopted him, whom should we
suppose more likely to have preserved the lineage of the adopting father, than that evangelist
671 Matt. i. 1–16.
672 Luke iii. 23–38.
673 In the Retractations (ii. 16), Augustin alludes to this passage with the view of correcting his statement
regarding the adoption. He tells us that, in speaking of the two several fathers whom Joseph may have had, he
should not have said that there “was one by whom Joseph was begotten, and another by whom he may have
been adopted,” but should rather have put it thus: “one by whom he was begotten, and another unto whom he
was adopted” (alteri instead of ab altero adoptatus). And the reason indicated for the correction is the probability
that the father who begat Joseph was the mother’s second husband, who, according to the Levirate law, had
married her on the death of his brother without issue. [That Luke gives the lineage of Mary, who was the
daughter of Heli, has been held by many scholars. Weiss, in his edition of Meyer’s Commentary, claims that
this is the only grammatical view: see Robinson’s Greek Harmony, rev. ed. pp. 207, 208. Augustin passes over
this solution apparently because he was more concerned to press the priestly lineage of Mary.—R.]
674 Ex. ii. 10.
675 Gen. xlviii. 5, 6.
A Statement of the Reason Why Matthew Enumerates One Succession of Ancestors for Christ, and Luke Another.
227
A Statement of the Reason Why Matthew Enumerates One Succession of Ancestors…