The lack of deep theological conviction is shown in his
Dialogue against the Pelagians, where it is evident that he is far from
that original and deep view of human corruption which Augustin
maintained; indeed, he appears at times to be arguing against his own
side, when he says (471) that, “Till the end we are subject to
sin; not,” (as the opponent falsely imputes to him)
“through the fault of our nature and constitution, but through
frailty and the mutability of the human will, which varies from moment
to moment”—a sentence which might be taken as expressing
the doctrine of Pelagius himself. It is evident that in these cases he
is swayed not so much by the force of truth as by the authority of
certain powerful Bishops and the wish to maintain his orthodox
reputation. In his other controversies, with Helvidius, Jovinian, John,
Bishop of Jerusalem, Vigilantius, and Rufinus, his method is take for
granted the opinion current among the Christians of his day, and to
support it by copious (sometimes excessive) quotations from Scripture,
and by arguments sometimes well chosen and acutely maintained, as in
the book against Helvidius (339), sometimes of the most frivolous
character, as in that against Vigilantius (422). In the three last of
these controversies the opposition is embittered by personal feeling,
and Jerome hardly places any restraint on the contempt and hatred which
it engenders.