60. All everywhere tell us of the being of the
Word, but none of His being ‘by will,’ nor at all of His
making; but they, where, I ask, did they find will or pleasure
‘precedent προηγουμένην
and 61 fin. The antecedens voluntas has been mentioned
in Recogn. Clem. supr. note 11. For Ptolemy vid. Epiph.
Hær. p. 215. The Catholics, who allowed that our Lord
was θελήσει, explained it as a σύνδρομος
θέλησις,
and not a προηγουμένη; as Cyril. Trin. ii. p. 56. And with the same
meaning S. Ambrose, nec voluntas ante Filium nec potestas. de
Fid. v. 224. And S. Gregory Nyssen, ‘His immediate
union, ἄμεσος
συνάφεια, does not exclude the Father’s will, βούλησιν, nor does that will separate the Son from the
Father.’ contr. Eunom. vii. p. 206, 7. vid. the whole
passage. The alternative which these words, σύνδρομος
and προηγουμένη, expressed was this; whether an act of Divine Purpose or
Will took place before the Generation of the Son, or whether
both the Will and the Generation were eternal, as the Divine Nature was
eternal. Hence Bull says, with the view of exculpating Novatian, Cum
Filius dicitur ex Patre, quando ipse voluit, nasci. Velle illud Patris
æternum fuisse intelligendum. Defens. F. N. iii. 8.
§8.’ to the Word
of God, unless forsooth, leaving the Scriptures, they simulate the
perverseness of Valentinus? For Ptolemy the Valentinian said that the
Unoriginate had a pair of attributes, Thought and Will, and first He
thought and then He willed; and what He thought, He could not put
forth προβάλλειν, de Syn. 16, n. 8., unless when the power of the Will was
added. Thence the Arians taking a lesson, wish will and pleasure to
precede the Word. For them then, let them rival the doctrine of
Valentinus; but we, when we read the divine discourses, found ‘He
was’ applied to the Son, but of Him only did we hear as being in
the Father and the Father’s Image; while in the case of things
originate only, since also by nature these things once were not, but
afterwards came to be ἐπιγέγονε, Or. i. 25, 28 fin. iii. 6., did we recognise a
precedent will and pleasure, David saying in the hundred and thirteenth
Psalm, ‘As for our God He is in heaven, He hath done whatsoever
pleased Him,’ and in the hundred and tenth, ‘The works of
the Lord are great, sought out unto all His good pleasure;’ and
again, in the hundred and thirty-fourth, ‘Whatsoever the Lord
pleased, that did He in heaven, and in earth, and in the sea, and in
all deep places Ps. cxv. 3; cxi. 2. LXX.;
cxxxv. 6..’ If then He
be work and thing made, and one among others, let Him, as others, be
said ‘by will’ to have come to be, and Scripture shews that
these are thus brought into being. And Asterius, the advocate Cf.
ii. n. 1. for the heresy, acquiesces, when he thus
writes, ‘For if it be unworthy of the Framer of all, to make at pleasure, let His
being pleased be removed equally in the case of all, that His Majesty
be preserved unimpaired. Or if it be befitting God to will, then let
this better way obtain in the case of the first Offspring. For it is
not possible that it should be fitting for one and the same God to make
things at His pleasure, and not at His will also.’ In spite of
the Sophist having introduced abundant irreligion in his words, namely,
that the Offspring and the thing made are the same, and that the Son is
one offspring out of all offsprings that are, He ends with the
conclusion that it is fitting to say that the works are by will and
pleasure.