a murderer,—I answer that I do not allow that I too am made a traditor and a murderer by
the sins of other men, just because you confess that you are made a thief by the sin of another
man; for it must be remembered that you are proved a thief, not by our judgment, but by
your own confession. For we say that every man must bear his own burden, as the apostle
is our witness.2050 But you, of your own accord, have taken the burden of Optatus on your
own shoulders, not because you committed the theft, or consented to it, but because you
declared your conviction that what another did applied to you. For, as the apostle says,
when speaking of food, "I know, and am persuaded by the Lord Jesus, that there is nothing
unclean of itself: but to him that esteemeth anything to be unclean, to him it is unclean;"2051
by the same rule, it may be said that the sins of others cannot implicate those who disapprove
of them; but if any one thinks that they affect him, then he is affected by them. Wherefore
you do not convict us of being traditors or murderers, even though you were to prove
something of the sort against those who share the sacraments with us; but the guilt of theft
is fastened on you, even if you disapprove of everything that Optatus did, not in virtue of
our accusation, but by your own decision. And that you may not think this a trivial fault,
read what the apostle says, "Nor shall thieves inherit the kingdom of God."2052 But those
who shall not inherit the kingdom of God will certainly not be on His right hand among
those whom it shall be said, "Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared
for you from the foundation of the world." If they are not there, where will they be except
on the left hand? Therefore among those to whom it shall be said, "Depart from me, ye
cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels."2053 In vain, therefore,
do you indulge in your security, thinking it a trivial fault which separates you from the
545
kingdom of God, and sends you into everlasting fire. How much better will you do to betake
yourself to true confusion, saying, Every one of us shall bear his own burden, and the win-
nowing fan at the last day shall separate the chaff from the wheat!
55. But it is evident that you are afraid of its being forthwith said to you, "Why then,
whilst you attempt to place on some men’s backs the burdens of their neighbors, have you
dared to separate yourselves from the Lord’s corn, dispersed throughout the world, before
the winnowing at the last day?" Accordingly, you who disapprove of the deeds of your party,
whilst you are taking precautions against being charged with the schism which you all have
made, are involving yourselves also in their sins which you did not commit; and while the
shrewd Petilianus is afraid of my being able to say that am I not such as he thinks Cæcilianus
was, he is obliged to confess that he himself is such as he knows Optatus to have been. Or
2050 Gal. vi. 5.
2051 Rom. xiv. 14.
2052 1 Cor. vi. 10.
2053 Matt. xxv. 34, 41.
1047
Chapter 23