than moral sincerity, as Mr. W. says. Mr. W. supposes that God requires us, before we admit
persons, to seek credible evidence of true piety, and to see to it that we have reasonable
ground to believe they have it; otherwise, not to allow them to come; and yet that God does
not look on such a qualification requisite in itself, when all is done, and that he has given
them as true and lawful a right to come without it, as with it. If God insists upon it, as Mr.
W. supposes, that members should be admitted under no other notion than of their being
truly godly, and from respect to such a character appearing on them, is it not plain, that
God looks on such a character in itself requisite, in order to a person’s being a rightful subject
of such a privilege. If the want of this qualification do not in the least hinder a person’s
lawful right to a thing, on what account can the want of an appearance of it and pretence
to it, warrant and oblige others to hinder his taking possession of that thing?
That we should be obliged to require a credible pretence and evidence of the being of
a thing, in order to a certain purpose, the being of which is not requisite to that purpose; or
that some evidence of a thing should be necessary, and yet withal no necessity there should
be any foundation of such evidence, in the being of the thing to be made evident; that it
should be necessary for us to seek evidence that something is true, and yet there be no need
in order to the intended purpose, that there be any such truth to be made evident;—if these
things are the dictates of common sense, I am willing all that are possessed of any degree of
common sense should be judges.
If God has plainly revealed, that gospel-holiness is not necessary in itself in order to
men’s lawful right to sacraments, as Mr. W. greatly insists, then his churches need not believe
it to be necessary; yea, it is their duty to believe that it is not necessary, as it is their duty to
believe what God says to be true. But yet Mr. W. holds, that God forbids his churches to
admit any to sacraments, unless they first have some rational evidence obliging them to
believe that they have gospel-holiness. Now how palpable is the inconsistence, that we must
be obliged to believe men have a qualification in order to our suffering them to come, which
yet at the same time we need not believe to be necessary for them to have in order to their
coming, but which God requires us to believe to be unnecessary! Or in other words, that
God has made it necessary for us to believe or suppose men are truly pious, in order to our
lawfully allowing them to take the sacraments, and yet at the same time requires us to believe
no such thing as their being pious is necessary in order to their lawfully taking the sacraments!
Mr. Stoddard (whose principles Mr. W. in Preface, p. 3. a. declares himself to be fully
established in) not only says, that some unsanctified men have a right before God to the
Lord’s supper, but strongly asserts, over and over, that they are fit to be admitted to the
Lord’s supper, that they are duly qualified, fit matter for church-membership—(Appeal, p.
15, 16.) And Mr. W. argues that such qualifications as some unsanctified men have, are
suffient to bring them into the church. Now if it be so, what business have we to demand
evidence or pretence of any thing further. What case in the world can be mentioned parallel
1926
SECTION III. Of ungodly men's communing.