(ii) The Religious History,
several times referred to in the Ecclesiastical History, and therefore
an earlier composition, contains the lives of thirty-three famous
ascetics, of whom three were women. The “curious intellectual
problem” Canon Venables Dict. Christ. Biog. iv. 918. of the readiness with which
Theodoret, a disciple of the “prosaic and critical” school
of Antioch, accepts and repeats marvellous tales of the miracles of his
contemporary hermits, has been invested with fresh interest in our own
time by the apparent sympathy and similar belief of Dr. Newman, who
asks “What made him drink in with such relish what we reject with
such disgust? Was it that, at least, some miracles were brought home so
absolutely to his sensible experience that he had no reason for
doubting the others which came to him second-hand? This certainly will
explain what to most of us is sure to seem the stupid credulity of so
well-read, so intellectual an author.” Historical Sketches iii.
314.
Cardinal Newman evidently implies that the evidence was irresistible,
even to a keen and trained intelligence. Probably in many cases the
explanation is to be found, as has been already suggested in the
remarks on Theodoret’s birth, in the ready acceptance of the
current views of the age and place as to cause and effect. Theodoret
believed in the marvels of his monks. Matthew Hale believed in
witchcraft.
Neither, that is, was some centuries removed from his own age. Neither
need be accused of stupid credulity. The enthusiasm which led him to
reckon on finding the noble army of martyrs a very present help in time
of trouble because he had a little bottle of their oil, probably that
burned at their graves, slung over his bed; and his assurance that the
old cloak of Jacobus, folded for his pillow, was a more than adamantine
bulwark against the wiles of the devil, indicate no more than an
exaggerated reliance on the power of material memorials to affect the
imagination. Theod. Ed. Migne. iii. 1244. Schröckh. xviii. 362. And it is curious to remark that with
all this acceptance of the cures effected by ascetics, Theodoret made a
provision of medical skill for his flock at Cyrus. Ep.
CXV.