Still I cannot see what profit
there is in deigning to examine such nonsense. For a man like myself,
who has lived to gray hairs This
cannot have been written earlier than 384. The preceding twelve books,
of which an instalment only was read to Gregory the Nazianzene and
others during the Council of Constantinople, 381, must have occupied
him a considerable time: and there may have been an interval after that
before this essay was composed., and whose eyes are
fixed on truth alone, to take upon his lips the absurd and flippant
utterances of a contentious foe, incurs no slight danger of bringing
condemnation on himself. I will therefore pass over both those words
and the adjoining passage; this, for instance, “Truth gives no
evidence of any union of natures with God.” Well, if these words
had not been spoken, who ever was there (except yourself) who mentioned
a double nature in the Deity at all? You, however, unite each idea of
each name with the essence of the Father, and deny that anything
externally accrues to Him, centering every one of His names in that
essence. Again, “Neither does she write in the statute-book of
our religion any idea that is external and fabricated by
ourselves.” With regard to these words again I shall deprecate
the idea that I have quoted them with a view of amusing the reader with
their absurdity; rather I have done so with a view to show with what a
slender equipment of arguments this man, after rating us for our want
of system, advances to take these audacious liberties with the name of
Truth. What is he in reasoning, and what is he in speech, that he
should thus revel in showing himself off before his hidebound readers,
who applaud him as victorious over everybody by force of argument when
he has brought these disjointed utterances of his dry bombastic jargon to
an end τὰς
στομφώδεις…ξηροστομίας
κακοσυνθέτως
διαπεραίνοντα. The editt. have διαπεραίνοντες, which Gulonius’ Latin follows, “arrogantes
has sicci oris voces malâ compositione trajicientes,”
i.e. his hearers get through them with bad
pronunciation.. “Immortality,” he says,
“is the essence itself.” But what, then, do you assert to
be the essence of the Only-begotten? I ask you that: is it immortality,
or is it not? For remember that in His essence also the singleness
admits, as you say, of no complexity of nature. If, then Eunomius
denies that immortality is the essence of the Son, it is clear what he
is aiming at; for it does not require an exceedingly penetrating
understanding to discover what is the direct opposite to the immortal.
Just as the logic of dichotomy exhibits the destructible instead of the
indestructible, and the mutable instead of the immutable, so it
exhibits the mortal instead of the immortal. What, therefore, will this
setter forth of new doctrine do? What proper name will he give us for
the essence of the Only-begotten? Again I put this question to our
author. He must either grant that it is immortality, or deny it. If,
then, he will not assent to its being immortality, he must assent to
the contradictory proposition; by negativing the superior term he
proves that it is death. If, on the other hand, he shrinks from
anything so monstrous, and names the essence of the Only-begotten also
as immortality, he must perforce agree with us that there is in
consequence no difference whatever, as to essence, between them. If the
nature of the Father and the nature of the Son are equally immortality,
and if immortality does not divide itself by any manner of difference,
then it is confessed by our foes themselves, that on the score of
essence no manner of difference is discoverable between the Father and
the Son.