Few writers deserve their place in the library of Nicene
and Post-Nicene Fathers more thoroughly than Hilary. He might be
said to be the one Latin theologian before the age of St. Augustine and
St. Leo. Tertullian had a still greater influence upon the
writers who followed him. He came at a still more formative and
critical time, and the vis vivida of his original and wayward
genius has rarely been equalled. But the particular influence
which Tertullian exerted in coining the terms and marking out the main
lines of Latin theology came to him almost by accident. He was
primarily a lawyer, and his special gift did not lie in the region of
speculation. It is a strange fortune which gave to the language
on which he set his stamp so great a control of the future. The
influence of Hilary on the other hand is his by right. His
intercourse with the East had a marked effect upon him. It
quickened a natural bent for speculation unusual in the West. The
reader will find in Mr. Watson’s Introduction a description and
estimate of Hilary’s theology which is in my opinion at once
accurate, candid and judicious. No attempt is made to gloss over
the defects, especially in what we might call the more superficial
exegesis of Hilary’s argument; but behind and beneath this we
feel that we are in contact with a very powerful mind. We feel
that we are in contact with a mind that has seized and holds fast the
central truth of the Christian system, which at that particular crisis
of the Church’s history was gravely imperiled. The nerve of
all Hilary’s thinking lies in his belief, a belief to which he
clung more tenaciously than to life itself, that Christ was the Son of
God not in name and metaphor only, but in fullest and deepest
reality. The great Athanasius himself has not given to this
belief a more impressive or more weighty expression. And when
like assaults come round, as they are constantly doing, in what is in
many respects the inferior arena of our own day, it is both morally
bracing and intellectually helpful to go back to these protagonists of
the elder time.