Chapter 20.—44. Petilianus said: "The Lord Christ cries again from heaven to Paul,
‘Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me? It is hard for thee to kick against the pricks.’2035 He
was then called Saul, that he might afterwards receive his true name in baptism. But for
you it is not hard so often to persecute Christ in the persons of His priests, though the Lord
Himself cries out, ‘Touch not mine anointed.’2036 Reckon up all the deaths of the saints,
and so often have you murdered Christ, who lives in each of them.2037 Lastly, if you are
not guilty of sacrilege, then a saint cannot be a murderer."
45. Augustin answered: Defend yourselves from the charge of the persecution which
those men suffered at the hands of your party who separated themselves from you with the
followers of Maximianus, and therein you will find our defence. For if you say that you
committed no such deeds, we simply read to you the records of the pro-consular province
and the state. If you say that you were right in persecuting them, why are you unwilling to
suffer the like yourselves? If you say, "But we caused no schism," then let this be inquired
into, and, till it is decided whether it be so or not, let no one make accusation against perse-
cutors. If you say that even schismatics ought not to have suffered persecution, I ask
whether it is also the case that they ought not to have been driven out of the basilicas, in
which they lay snares for the leading astray of the weak, even though it were done by duly
constituted authorities? If you say that this also should not have been done, first restore the
basilicas to the followers of Maximianus, and then discuss the point with us. If you say that
it was right, then see what they ought to suffer at the hands of duly constituted authority,
who, in resisting it, "resist the ordinance of God." Wherefore the apostle expressly says,
"For he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute
wrath on him that doeth evil." 2038 But even if this had been discovered after the truth had
been searched out with all diligence, that not even after public trial ought schismatics to
undergo any punishment, or be driven from the positions which they have occupied, for
their treachery and deceit; and if you should say that you are vexed that the followers of
Maximianus should have suffered such conduct at the hands of some of you,—why does
not the wheat of the Lord cry out with the more freedom from the whole field of the Lord,
that is, from the world, and say, Neither are we at all affected by what the tares and the chaff
amongst us do, seeing that it is contrary to our wish? If you confess that it is sufficient to
2035 Acts ix. 4, 5.
2036 Ps. cv. 15.
2037 Vivacem Christum.
2038 Rom. xiii. 2, 4.
Chapter 20
1039
Chapter 20