(c) Commencement of the second exile. Here
again the agreement of our chronicles is constructive only, owing to
the loss of the earlier part of the Hist. Aceph.; but it is none
the less certain. The exile ended, as everyone now admits and as both
chronicles tell us, on Paoph. 24 (Oct. 21), 346: it lasted, according
to the H. A., seven years, six months, and three days. This
carries us back to Phar. 21 (April 16), 339. Now we learn from the
Index that he left the Church of Theonas on the night of Mar.
18–19, and from the Encyclical, 4, 5, that he took refuge
first in another church, then in some secret place till over Easter
Sunday (Apr. 15). This fits exactly with Apr. 16 as the date of his
flight to Rome. To this there is only one serious objection, viz., that
Ath. was summoned (p. 239) to Milan by Constantius after the end of
three years from his leaving Alexandria. It has been assumed (without
any proof) that this took place ‘just before’ the council
of Sardica. As a matter of fact, Constans left Athan. in Milan, and
(apparently after his summer campaign) ordered him to follow him to
Trier, in order to travel thence to the Council. Athanasius does not
state either how long he remained at Milan, or when he was ordered to
Trier; for a chronological inference, in opposition to explicit
evidence, he furnishes no basis whatever. I agree with Mr. Gwatkin
(whom his Reviewer quite misunderstands) in placing the Milan interview
about May, 342, and the journey from Trier to Sardica after Easter
(probably later still) in 343 (Constans was in Britain in the spring of
343, and had returned to Trier before June 30, Cod. Th. XII. i.
36, see also supr. p. xlv.). A more reasonable objection to the
statement of the Index is that of Dr. Bright (p. xv. note 5),
who sets against its information that Athan. fled from
‘Theonas’ four days before Gregory’s arrival, the
statement of the Encyclical that he left a certain church
after Gregory’s outrages at Eastertide. But clearly Athan.
first escaped from the church of Theonas, afterwards (between Good
Friday and Easter) from some other church (ἄλλη
ἐκκλησία), not named
by him (‘Quirinus,’ cf. p. 95, note 1), and finally from
the City itself. (Dr. Bright’s arguments in favour of 340 are
vitiated in part by his placing Easter on April 9, i.e. on a Wednesday,
instead of the proper day, Sunday, Mar. 30). The date, April 16, 339,
is, therefore, well established as the beginning of the second exile,
and there is no tangible evidence against it. It is, moreover,
supported by the subscription to the letter to Serapion, which stands
in the stead of the Easter letter for 340, and which states that the
letter was written from Rome.