Chapter XIII.—Of the Inconsistencies of the Psychics.
You lay down a prescription that this faith has its solemnities “appointed” by the
Scriptures or the tradition of the ancestors; and that no further addition in the way of ob-
servance must be added, on account of the unlawfulness of innovation. Stand on that
ground, if you can. For, behold, I impeach you of fasting besides on the Paschal-day, beyond
the limits of those days in which “the Bridegroom was taken away;” and interposing the
half-fasts of Stations; and you, (I find), sometimes living on bread and water, when it has
seemed meet to each (so to do). In short, you answer that “these things are to be done of
choice, not of command.” You have changed your ground, therefore, by exceeding tradition,
in undertaking observances which have not been “appointed.” But what kind of deed is it,
to permit to your own choice what you grant not to the command of God? Shall human
volition have more licence than Divine power? I am mindful that I am free from the world,
1093 not from God. Thus it is my part to perform, without external suggestion thereto, an
act of respect to my Lord, it is His to enjoin. I ought not merely to pay a willing obedience
to Him, but withal to court Him; for the former I render to His command, the latter to my
own choice.
But it is enough for me that it is a customary practice for the bishops withal to issue
mandates for fasts to the universal commonalty of the Church; I do not mean for the special
purpose of collecting contributions of alms, as your beggarly fashion has it, but sometimes
too from some particular cause of ecclesiastical solicitude. And accordingly, if you practise
ταπεινοφρόνησις at the bidding of a man’s edict, and all unitedly, how is it that in our case
you set a brand upon the very unity also of our fastings, and xerophagies, and Stations?—un-
less, perhaps, it is against the decrees of the senate and the mandates of the emperors which
are opposed to “meetings” that we are sinning! The Holy Spirit, when He was preaching in
whatsoever lands He chose, and through whomsoever He chose, was wont, from foresight
of the imminence either of temptations to befall the Church, or of plagues to befall the world,
in His character of Paraclete (that is, Advocate for the purpose of winning over the judge
by prayers), to issue mandates for observances of this nature; for instance, at the present
time, with the view of practising the discipline of sobriety and abstinence: we, who receive
Him, must necessarily observe also the appointments which He then made. Look at the
Jewish calendar, and you will find it nothing novel that all succeeding posterity guards with
hereditary scrupulousness the precepts given to the fathers. Besides, throughout the provinces
of Greece there are held in definite localities those councils gathered out of the universal
Churches, by whose means not only all the deeper questions are handled for the common
benefit, but the actual representation of the whole Christian name is celebrated with great
veneration. (And how worthy a thing is this, that, under the auspices of faith, men should
1093 1 Cor. ix. 19; sæculo.
Of the Inconsistencies of the Psychics.
250
Of the Inconsistencies of the Psychics.