meditatio passes with the utmost ease into oratio, and his oratio into meditatio. With pro-
fundity he combined an equal clearness and sharpness of thought. He was an extremely
skilful and a successful dialectician, inexhaustible in arguments and in answers to the objec-
tions of his adversaries.
He has enriched Latin literature with a greater store of beautiful, original, and pregnant
proverbial sayings, than any classic author, or any other teacher of the church.20
8
He had a creative and decisive hand in almost every dogma of the Latin church, com-
pleting some, and advancing others. The centre of his system is the free redeeming grace of
God in Christ, operating through the actual, historical church. He is evangelical or Pauline
in his doctrine of sin and grace, but catholic (that is, old-catholic, not Roman Catholic) in
his doctrine of the church. The Pauline element comes forward mainly in the Pelagian
controversy, the catholic-churchly in the Donatist; but each is modified by the other.
Dr. Baur incorrectly makes freedom the fundamental idea of the Augustinian system.
But this much better suits the Pelagian; while Augustin started (like Calvin and Schleier-
macher) from the idea of the absolute dependence of man upon God. He changed his idea
of freedom during the Pelagian controversy. Baur draws an ingenious and suggestive com-
parison between Augustin and Origen, the two greatest intellects among the church fathers.
“There is no church teacher of the ancient period,” says he,21“who, in intellect and in
grandeur and consistency of view, can more justly be placed by the side of Origen than
Augustin; none who, with all the difference in individuality and in mode of thought, so
closely resembles him. How far both towered above their times, is most clearly manifest in
20 Prosper Aquitanus collected in the year 450 or 451 from the works of Augustin 392 sentences (see the
Appendix to the tenth vol. of the Bened. ed. p. 223 sqq., and in Migne’s ed. of Prosper Aquitanus, col. 427–496),
with reference to theological purport and the Pelagian controversies. We recall some of the best which he has
omitted: “Novum Testamentum in Vetere latet, Vetus in Novo pates.” “Distingue tempora, et concordabit
Scriptura.” “Cor nostrum inquietum est, donec requiescat in Te.” “Da quod jubes, et jube quod vis.” “Non vincit
nisi veritas, victoria veritatis est caritas.” “Ubi amor, ibi trinitas.” “Fides præcedit intellectum.” “Deo servire vera
libertas est.” “Nulia infelicitas frangit, quem felicitas nulla corrumpit.” The famous maxim of ecclesiastical har-
mony: “In necessarlis unitas, in dublis (or, non ccessarlis) libertas, in omnibus (in utrisque) caritas,”—which is
often ascribed to Augustin, dates in this form not from him, but from a much later period. Dr. Lucke (in a special
treatise on the antiquity of the author, the original form, etc., of this sentence, Göttingen, 1850) traces the au-
thorship to Rupert Meldenius, an irenical German theologian of the seventeenth century. Baxter, also, who lived
during the intense conflict of English Puritanism and Episcopacy, and grew weary of the “fury of theologians,”
adopted a similar sentiment. The sentence is held by many who differ widely in the definition of what is “neces-
sary” and what is “doubtful.” The meaning of “charity in all things” is above doubt, and a moral duty of every
Christian, though practically violated by too many in all denominations.
21 Vorlesungen über die christl. Dogmengeschichte, vol. 1. P. 11. p. 30 sq.
20
Estimate of St. Augustin