This would seem to be a reference to the Donatists. If it is, it
leads us to suppose that Constantine had heard about the troubles in
Carthage before he received the communication from Anulinus referred to
in the previous chapter; for we can hardly suppose that pending the
trial of Cæcilian Constantine would show him such signal marks of
favor, which would lay him at once open to the charge of partiality,
and would be practically a prejudgment of the case. On the other hand,
he could not have referred to the Donatists in this way after the trial
of the case, for his words imply that he is referring, not to an
already well-established and well-known party, but simply to
individuals whom he has recently learned to be making some kind of
trouble in the church. These considerations seem to me to lead to the
conclusion that this epistle preceded the one to Miltiades quoted in
the previous chapter, and also the one from Anulinus to Constantine
(see notes 16 and 19 on that chapter). If this be so, it must have been
written as early as April, 313, and therefore soon after the epistle to
Anulinus quoted in the previous chapter, § 15 sq. We might then be
led to suppose that it was in consequence of this grant made by
Constantine solely to Cæcilian and the clergy under him that the
Donatists decided to appeal to the emperor, his treatment of all who
were opposed to Cæcilian showing them that he had heard reports of
them by no means to their advantage, and thus impelling them to try and
set themselves right in his eyes and in the eyes of the world by a
public investigation of their cause. There are difficulties connected
with the exact order of events at this point which beset any theory we
may adopt, but the one just stated seems to me most in harmony with our
sources and with the nature of the case. For a full, though not
altogether satisfactory, discussion of the matter, which I cannot dwell
upon here, see Walch’s Ketzergeschichte, IV. p. 116
sq.