We notice, in the first place, that he was very diligent in the use of his sources. Nothing
seems to have escaped him that might in any way bear upon the particular subject in hand.
When he informs us that a certain author nowhere mentions a book or an event, he is, so
far as I am aware, never mistaken. When we realize how many works he read entirely through
for the sake of securing a single historical notice, and how many more he must have read
without finding anything to his purpose, we are impressed with his untiring diligence. To-
day, with our convenient indexes, and with the references at hand which have been made
by many other men who have studied the writings of the ancients, we hardly comprehend
what an amount of labor the production of a History like Eusebius’ must have cost him, a
pioneer in that kind of work.
In the second place, we are compelled to admire the sagacity which our author displays
in the selection of his materials. He possessed the true instinct of the historian, which enabled
him to pick out the salient points and to present to the reader just that information which
he most desires. We shall be surprised upon examining his work to see how little it contains
which it is not of the utmost importance for the student of early Church history to know,
and how shrewdly the author has anticipated most of the questions which such a student
must ask. He saw what it was in the history of the first three centuries of the Church which
posterity would most desire to know, and he told them. His wisdom in this respect is all the
more remarkable when compared with the unwisdom of most of his successors, who filled
their works with legends of saints and martyrs, which, however fascinating they may have
been to the readers of that age, possess little either of interest or of value for us. When he
wishes to give us a glimpse of the persecutions of those early days, his historical and literary
instinct leads him to dwell especially upon two thoroughly representative cases,—the mar-
tyrdom of Polycarp and the sufferings of the churches of Lyons and Vienne,—and to preserve
for posterity two of the noblest specimens of martyrological literature which the ancient
Church produced. It is true that he sometimes erred in his judgment as to the wants of future
readers; we could wish that he had been somewhat fuller and clearer on many points, and
that he had not so entirely neglected some others; but on the whole I am of the opinion that
few historical works, ancient or modern, have in the same compass better fulfilled their
mission in this respect.
In the third place, we can hardly fail to be impressed by the wisdom with which Eusebius
discriminated between reliable and unreliable sources. Judged by the modern standard he
may fall short as a literary critic, but judged by the standard of antiquity he must be given
a very high rank. Few indeed are the historians of ancient times, secular or ecclesiastical,
who can compare with Eusebius for sound judgment in this matter. The general freedom
of his work from the fables and prodigies, and other improbable or impossible tales which
disfigure the pages of the great majority even of the soberest of ancient historians, is one of
its most marked features. He shows himself uncommonly particular in demanding good
73
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.