more plainly. They only know of four ancient General Councils—those of Nice, Con-
stantinople, Ephesus, and Chalcedon. The objection of the Ballerini that Gregory and Isidore
did not intend to enumerate the most ancient general synods as such, but only those which
issued important dogmatic decrees, is plainly quite arbitrary, and therefore without force.
Under such circumstances it is natural that among the later scholars by far the great majority
should have answered the question, whether the Synod of Sardica is ecumenical, in the
negative, as have Cardinal Bellarmin, Peter de Marca, Edmund Richer, Fleury, Orsi, Sacharelli,
Tillemont, Du Pin, Berti, Ruttenstock, Rohrbacher, Remi Ceillier, Stolberg, Neander, and
others. On the other hand, Baronius, Natalis Alexander, the brothers Ballerini, Mansi, and
Palma416 have sought to maintain the ecumenical character of the synod, but as early as the
seventeenth century the Roman censors condemned the direct assertions of Natalis Alexander
on the subject.
416 Jno. Bapt. Palma. Prælectiones Hist. Eccl. quas in Collegio Urbano habuit. Rome, l838. Tom. i., P. ii., p.
85.
802
Excursus as to Whether the Sardican Council Was Ecumenical.