27. This then is what the irreligious men allege
in their discourses; and if they thus argue, they might consistently
speak yet more daringly; ‘Why did the Word become flesh at
all?’ and they might add; ‘For how could He, being God,
become man?’ or, ‘How could the Immaterial bear a
body?’ or they might speak with Caiaphas still more Judaically,
‘Wherefore at all did Christ, being a man, make Himself God De
Decr. 1; Or. i. 4.?’ for this and the like the Jews then
muttered when they saw, and now the Ario-maniacs disbelieve when they
read, and have fallen away into blasphemies. If then a man should
carefully parallel the words of these and those, he will of a certainty
find them both arriving at the same unbelief, and the daring of their
irreligion equal, and their dispute with us a common one. For the Jews
said; ‘How, being a man, can He be God?’ And the Arians,
‘If He were very God from God, how could He become man?’
And the Jews were offended then and mocked, saying, ‘Had He been
Son of God, He had not endured the Cross;’ and the Arians
standing over against them, urge upon us, ‘How dare ye say that
He is the Word proper to the Father’s Essence, who had a body, so
as to endure all this?’ Next, while the Jews sought to kill the
Lord, because He said that God was His own Father and made Himself
equal to Him, as working what the Father works, the Arians also, not
only have learned to deny, both that He is equal to God and that God is
the own and natural Father of the Word, but those who hold this they
seek to kill. Again, whereas the Jews said, ‘Is not this the Son
of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? how then is it that He
saith, Before Abraham was, I am, and I came down from heaven John vi. 42; viii.
58.?’ the Arians on the other hand make
response ἐπακούουσιν. Montfaucon (Onomasticon in t. 2 fin.) so interprets this
word. vid. Apol. contr. Ar. 88. note 7. and say conformably, ‘How can He
be Word or God who slept as man, and wept, and inquired?’ Thus
both parties deny the Eternity and Godhead of the Word in consequence
of those human attributes which the Saviour took on Him by reason of
that flesh which He bore.